GRcade

There can't be six seers. Surely?

Drumstick wrote:Hey guys remember when I said we should target the quieter players:

PaperMacheMario wrote:I agree that I don’t think we should just target inactives

I really can’t wait for this game to end to discuss it with everyone.

PaperMacheMario wrote:

Drumstick wrote:Hey guys remember when I said we should target the quieter players:

PaperMacheMario wrote:I agree that I don’t think we should just target inactives

I really can’t wait for this game to end to discuss it with everyone.

You owe Mini E a Subway mate. Also why kill me off and not Mini E? I've never done anything to you in these games.

Nice shot.

I'd hoped there wasn't any protective roles in this, because what has happened previously is that the Mayor position is rotated between Witch Doctor and See and the wolves can't do anything about it (which IMO is slightly unfair and why I excluded the role entirely in the games I ran). A way to still include the WD but leveling it out is to give the WD a finite amount of times they can use the ability.

I still reckon this is an OR mafia play. He's ballsy enough to try it and ive picked my hill to die on already.

Plus I'm skeptical that a bodyguard would be able to protect themselves as it would create a scenario where they're basically immune to night kills by alternating with mayoral protection. He's banking on Mommy being the only seer left and so Mommy not bothering to check him.

Drumstick wrote:I'd hoped there wasn't any protective roles in this, because what has happened previously is that the Mayor position is rotated between Witch Doctor and See and the wolves can't do anything about it (which IMO is slightly unfair and why I excluded the role entirely in the games I ran). A way to still include the WD but leveling it out is to give the WD a finite amount of times they can use the ability.

When there is a protection from a kill doesn't the write-up by the game runner normally indicate there's been a failed attempt? Perhaps OR is a wolf and only ordered the 1 kill so that he could make this play.

sawyerpip wrote:

Drumstick wrote:I'd hoped there wasn't any protective roles in this, because what has happened previously is that the Mayor position is rotated between Witch Doctor and See and the wolves can't do anything about it (which IMO is slightly unfair and why I excluded the role entirely in the games I ran). A way to still include the WD but leveling it out is to give the WD a finite amount of times they can use the ability.

When there is a protection from a kill doesn't the write-up by the game runner normally indicate there's been a failed attempt? Perhaps OR is a wolf and only ordered the 1 kill so that he could make this play.

No, it's normal for there to be no mention of the kill that failed. It's on the players to work it out (in this case, however, Orange has provided an explanation for them).

Nun wrote:I still reckon this is an OR mafia play. He's ballsy enough to try it and ive picked my hill to die on already.

Plus I'm skeptical that a bodyguard would be able to protect themselves as it would create a scenario where they're basically immune to night kills by alternating with mayoral protection. He's banking on Mommy being the only seer left and so Mommy not bothering to check him.

This was commonplace in GR mafia games for about a decade until I removed the bodyguard role.

Ah, that's a pity. I think if I was going to use a mayor type of playstyle I'd probably have to use a Jailor then. Roleblock and protect so they can't use their action if they're protected.

Though that opens interactions with it being used offensively to roleblock mafians I suppose.

Edit: In fact if I just give the mafians a booker then that stops the interaction entirely. Mafia hookers were always pretty common in ONM games.

Drumstick wrote:

PaperMacheMario wrote:

Drumstick wrote:Hey guys remember when I said we should target the quieter players:

PaperMacheMario wrote:I agree that I don’t think we should just target inactives

I really can’t wait for this game to end to discuss it with everyone.

You owe Mini E a Subway mate. Also why kill me off and not Mini E? I've never done anything to you in these games.

Because you’re one of the better players, plus I knew Mini E suspected me so thought if we offer him I might be lynched if he’d told others of his suspicious.

And I don’t owe him a subway, that was only if neither of us were special roles.

Protection circles.

Up yours wolf bastards.

Mommy going after Moggy again. If Moggy is the Alpha and he's had three seers PM him their role

sawyerpip wrote:Mommy going after Moggy again. If Moggy is the Alpha and he's had three seers PM him their role

If he is the alpha he is a banana split, and has played a blinder.

Top of Page 52, post from OR saying he didn't run for mayor Day 1 because he believed Mommy needed the protection more than him.

Plus he apparently wanted to keep the option of Mayoral protection open for Day 2.

And he's now claiming Witch Doctor who can protect himself, I just can't buy it.

Mommy didn't get protection or Mayor on Day 1... so he was completely unprotected.

Did the wolves kill 3 inactives Day 1? They might not have been able to kill him even if they'd wanted to.

I wonder why I was killed. I'm not exactly a good player and I don't think I actually added anything to the human side or accused any of the right people of Wolfism.

I think Moggy is innocent, but what's funny is that he replied to a PM of mine shortly after I'd been killed which suggested he thought I was still alive. So if he does end up being the Alpha he was playing me even after killing me