Are You A Gangster 2: A New Menace - Day 3 - Jessica Fletcher Executed

This might be unpopular but as Jessica Fletcher hasn't posted, we could vote for her.

There's literally nothing to go on, but if someone isn't going to be around...

2 neutrals seemed high on first thought but could be a possibility based on some of this thinking.

Also yeah I'm not seeing 10 roles in the opening post - there are ten "groups" I guess (Town Support, Mafia Support, Neutral Benign etc.) but each group has multiple potential roles in play which makes things harder to nail down compared to if we knew the exact numbers and titles of roles in play

Thomas Magnum wrote:This might be unpopular but as Jessica Fletcher hasn't posted, we could vote for her.

There's literally nothing to go on, but if someone isn't going to be around...

It's strange to me that you would vote for us to make a lynch and then afterwards complain that there's no information available.

The inactive cull is quite aggressive this game so I would be against us lynching an inactive. I think we need at least 2 candidates so we can look at voting patterns later.

Hello everyone my name is Jessica fletcher and I wrote about and solve murders. 8-)

I’ve just woke up that’s why I hadn’t posted yet. :oops:

I didn't even realise there was a cull. :lol:

Off to the OP I go.

Okay, so it looks like everyone is present and correct.

I guess the tactic of lynching inactives isn't going to work this time.

Thomas Magnum wrote:,

Jane Marple wrote:,

Jessica fletcher wrote:,

Nancy Drew wrote:,

Thoughts on a role call? We don't have a lot of time to work with but if the people who are active in thread are game for it we could potentially look to get this started and then put some lynch votes towards people who don't claim to ramp up the pressure a little.

Shinichi Kudo wrote:
Thomas Magnum wrote:This might be unpopular but as Jessica Fletcher hasn't posted, we could vote for her.

There's literally nothing to go on, but if someone isn't going to be around...

It's strange to me that you would vote for us to make a lynch and then afterwards complain that there's no information available.

The inactive cull is quite aggressive this game so I would be against us lynching an inactive. I think we need at least 2 candidates so we can look at voting patterns later.

I voted for us to lynch because, well, if we don't use the numbers whilst they're on the side now, it's going to get harder the longer we leave it.

I am for a role call.

Shinichi Kudo wrote:
Thomas Magnum wrote:,

Jane Marple wrote:,

Jessica fletcher wrote:,

Nancy Drew wrote:,

Thoughts on a role call? We don't have a lot of time to work with but if the people who are active in thread are game for it we could potentially look to get this started and then put some lynch votes towards people who don't claim to ramp up the pressure a little.

Not sure I see the point of a roll call, especially as anyone role claiming an important positive role (and are not lying) would just open themselves up for being bludgeoned in their beds.

There's also the issue of gangster scum claiming positive roles too and causing confusion.

I just don't see how this could end well.

People who voted to lynch do we have any candidates on who we are lynching?

I do have a slight suspicion that Kouichi could be Jester/Executioner so is wanting a role call so that they can counterclaim someone to try and get either themself or their target lynched which is why I would prefer for them to start but if not I am tempted to get the ball rolling and claim myself if the other people who are active currently are onboard.

Nancy Drew wrote:Not sure I see the point of a roll call, especially as anyone role claiming an important positive role (and are not lying) would just open themselves up for being bludgeoned in their beds.

There's also the issue of gangster scum claiming positive roles too and causing confusion.

I just don't see how this could end well.

I think it's likely that we all have strong village alligned roles which it would be a shame were any of us to fall but by getting the information out into the open we can coordinate our night actions as well as narrowing the chance of lynching power roles today. Additionally gangsters claiming roles which are already taken immediately gives us a 50/50 between two players as to who isn't town. It's all about getting the information out early while we have a numbers advantage.

Interested to hear your alternative suggestion for who should be lynched?

Hercule Poirot wrote:People who voted to lynch do we have any candidates on who we are lynching?

Thoughts on a role call?

Shinichi Kudo wrote:Interested to hear your alternative suggestion for who should be lynched?

Perhaps we should be taking a closer look at Thomas Magnum?

He was first to want to lynch today, yet we all know that these early lynches are a crapshoot which often end up killing good guys unnecessarily.

I voted in favour yes, but since then I've had time to think and his eagerness for getting the noose out seems kinda off.

Perhaps his wanting an early lynch is a means of manipulating the odds in his favour a little? If so it's a bold move (and potentially risky), but certainly not something which should be discounted.

What a day. Just in the door and out again for a gathering.

This is my 3rd post as I understand it.
I'll catch up later, but apologies for my tardiness.

Frank Columbo wrote:This is my 3rd post as I understand it.
I'll catch up later, but apologies for my tardiness.

I believe the 3 posts have to be after 10am from my reading of the OP.

I hope you can come back and make a more constructive 3rd post after you've caught up :slol:

The lynch deadline today is 7pm, which gives us one hour to get our votes in!

I personally think a role call is a little premature. We have no way of verifying roles at this time and risk putting our key players in the line of fire. I think we need two or three names on the ballot tonight to improve our chances.

Shinichi Kudo wrote:
Hercule Poirot wrote:People who voted to lynch do we have any candidates on who we are lynching?

Thoughts on a role call?

Honestly, I'm completely unsure. I know people say it can be a genuinely good tactic, but having never experienced it I wouldn't know.

lynch vote wrote:Frank Columbo (1) - Jacques Clouseau

Getting things started. Reasoning at this point is limited. Frank was first to post, which can be a sign of an exciting role, plus has no avatar, which I believe was a tactic in a previous game to go un noticed.

My reasoning is not the strongest, as to be expected on day one, but of more importance is to get the vote going.

Nancy Drew wrote:
Shinichi Kudo wrote:Interested to hear your alternative suggestion for who should be lynched?

Perhaps we should be taking a closer look at Thomas Magnum?

He was first to want to lynch today, yet we all know that these early lynches are a crapshoot which often end up killing good guys unnecessarily.

I voted in favour yes, but since then I've had time to think and his eagerness for getting the noose out seems kinda off.

Perhaps his wanting an early lynch is a means of manipulating the odds in his favour a little? If so it's a bold move (and potentially risky), but certainly not something which should be discounted.

It's as good a suggestion as any other, I was a little confused by his earlier post lamenting the lack of leads after he voted for a lynch vote.

Although you yourself fall into the same category and have also been quite non-commital so far which is classic mafioso behavior.

Are You A Gangster 2: A New Menace - Day 3 - Jessica Fletcher Executed

Who is online

Affiliates