Are You A Werewolf? - GAME OVER

Yes, Shadow. Tomorrow will follow the same format as today.

WHAT THE ACTUAL strawberry float.

Catching up on PMs now.

JChalmers wrote:Right cant be furiosum, he's not been on since half 8.

DML is the only one with a private profile and everyone else has been on all night since the lynch so why did it take this long for the wolf to confim their kill? Normally it's straight after the lynchl....

Firstly, I didn't even KNOW I HAD a private profile.

This line of reasoning doesn't make any sense. I'm know perhaps you haven't dealt with werewolves (I've dealt with whole packs of the buggers) but basically, they don't tend to wait til lynch time to lynch. They will lynch early, they will lynch late, anything to throw people off the scent. If I was a wolf, I'd be PMing my picks as soon as the candidates for Mayor were announced, why wait and get picked up on later. That would be a stupid tactic.

If this is a deflection tactic because you've been our wolf all along Chalmers, I'm not impressed. I've been the target and the scapegoat all along, and guess what Chalmers? IT ISN'T GOING TO WORK. If you ARE a villager (which I am increasingly starting to doubt) then you need to realise thats the case. Killing me now would be so, so stupid when we've ascertained through multiple sources I'm basically mathematically innocent. I was a 1 in 17 chance at best when we had the seered and unseered lists, and since then I have voted for 6 wolves in votes. My stories have matched up with everyone who has questioned me. If you think that is all one big ruse, then strawberry floating kill me. You'll be wrong.

The obvious targets are those who have never ever backed wolves to die, or have barely backed wolves to die. What wolf is going to back five or six people to die? It doesn't make any strawberry floating sense. They were WINNING the game as well, why would anyone need to do that?

I dunno.. DML got a wolf though didn't he? Just how much suspicion was there on Songwriter before DML ran with him, was he suspected by anyone else before DML put him up? I did wonder why DML was set to hidden as he's only player left who's still doing it.. From what i noticed before a lot the wolves and other special roles were set to hidden, though a few villagers were as well.

Shadow got a wolf too, so unless he planned to sacrifice luke and under the bus then it's not him.

Furiosm tried to run with Ironhide and Dangerblade only Dangerblade got lynched. How much suspicion was there on Ironhide before Furiosm ran with him, do you think someone else would done it? I'm going to try and look through thread anyway but it doesn't hurt to ask.

PPM told me that he trusted DML and Jchalmers a few days ago. I presume he trusted DML because he caught Songwriter not sure why he said he trusted Jchalmers though. Jchalmers has not caught a wolf, not sure if he has run with one though.. Going to have to do more digging.

Sent a message to PPM just before he died asking why he trusted Jchalmers. So thanks for that by the way, wolf.

Honestly, I have no idea why I'm hidden. Its probably from a previous Werewolf game, its only with this one that the 'Whos Online' section has gone down. But that is the genuine truth, I have not set it for this game.

Shadow killing Luke is not as big of an achievement as me killing Songwriter (albeit with the e-mail), Luke was always going to die, it just so happened his time ran out with Shadow's lynch. I don't think theres a reasonable way he would have survived. No-one knew about Songwriter, if I was a wolf...why not kill Ironhide? If I recall everyone was already talking about him as a possible?

Someone has played a very good game, but it just doesn't make sense its me or Shadow. If it is Shadow, I will be literally speechless. It will be Herbi is the Alpha x 100.

PPM and I chatted a lot and I trusted his story implicitly. He trusted a lot of these guys, but obviously at this point someone was untrustworthy. Furiosum I don't trust full stop, and DayumChris, you just reappeared out of nowhere just as the heat was on. JChalmers is now turning the heat on me randomly against all common sense, so I hugely suspect him as well.

Lets put it another way. If me and Shadow are innocent, the wolf will ABSOLUTELY want one of us dead. We are a voting block of two, and two who will vote the same way, and two players voting the same way with five left is super, super dangerous. If that is the case, the wolf HAS to break up that block. Its desperation stakes. In fact the only way he can realistically win is if he kills BOTH me and Shadow with the lynch and then his Wolf Kill, leaving a blind alley for everyone else - IF we're both innocent.

That said, if Shadow's a wolf, I'm going to strawberry floating kill him.

Been looking through the thread..

Nun - PaperMacheMario & PCCD (1)
Zartan

PCCD - TAP & Qikz (0)

Shadow - DBlock and Qikz (4)
BID0, Albear, Errkal, JChalmers

Dblock - Zellery and Parksey (1)
Cribs

Pancake - Curls and JChalmers (6)
Luke_25, Kezzer, Qikz, Edd, PsychicSykes, Met

PPM - Zartan and Edd

Luke probably wouldnt have voted for Pancake if JChalmers was a wolf.


Furiosm made good point that Met was new so how did he know DML's email address and the fact Songwriter wasn't playing so would have been a good sacrifice. Met said Furiosm hasn't been behaving the way he usually does. Both of them could have been voting to stop MIni E getting in power and lynching Rik.

Fatal Exception wrote:

Dandy Kong wrote:

Mini-E - Riksilver and Kanbei
PPM , Errkal, Zellery, Chris, mic, Lagamorph, BID0, Tomous , Fatal Exception (9)

Dblock - "Vote for me and the wolves will get it"
Hank Scorpio, Qikz, Falsey, Kezzer, ianf, Shadow (6)

Pancake - Kanbei and jiggles
Dan, LewisD, Jay Adama, Albear, Nun (5)

Pacman - Tomous and Kanbei
Rhubarb, Edd, CheekyDevlin, Met, furiosum, Moggy, DML, Zartan, Rik, Yaoi, Dandy Kong (11)

My votes will be going to furiosum and JChalmers today. Both have started to attack me against most common sense, and have voted in comparably few wolves. DayumChris is at least open to a debate.

DML wrote:

JChalmers wrote:Right cant be furiosum, he's not been on since half 8.

DML is the only one with a private profile and everyone else has been on all night since the lynch so why did it take this long for the wolf to confim their kill? Normally it's straight after the lynchl....

Firstly, I didn't even KNOW I HAD a private profile.

This line of reasoning doesn't make any sense. I'm know perhaps you haven't dealt with werewolves (I've dealt with whole packs of the buggers) but basically, they don't tend to wait til lynch time to lynch. They will lynch early, they will lynch late, anything to throw people off the scent. If I was a wolf, I'd be PMing my picks as soon as the candidates for Mayor were announced, why wait and get picked up on later. That would be a stupid tactic.

If this is a deflection tactic because you've been our wolf all along Chalmers, I'm not impressed. I've been the target and the scapegoat all along, and guess what Chalmers? IT ISN'T GOING TO WORK. If you ARE a villager (which I am increasingly starting to doubt) then you need to realise thats the case. Killing me now would be so, so stupid when we've ascertained through multiple sources I'm basically mathematically innocent. I was a 1 in 17 chance at best when we had the seered and unseered lists, and since then I have voted for 6 wolves in votes. My stories have matched up with everyone who has questioned me. If you think that is all one big ruse, then strawberry floating kill me. You'll be wrong.

The obvious targets are those who have never ever backed wolves to die, or have barely backed wolves to die. What wolf is going to back five or six people to die? It doesn't make any strawberry floating sense. They were WINNING the game as well, why would anyone need to do that?

Think I've got a bite

Tbh it was just a moment of chat me and PPM had last night before he was killed. We were saying about how the kill wasn't right away like normal and I was watching furiosum's profile to see if he was active. I mentioned to PPM you were private and he was going to do some digging but said if you were a wolf it would absolutely kill him I think I might've taken that a bit too literal for the game as he was suddenly found dead straight after haha.

I can assure you I am a villager, only been playing the game the second half as I was out travelling for work the first half.

I do have suspicions on DayumChris, he wasn't playing longer than me, then when I was thinking of running for Mayor he suddenly PMs me out of the blue and asks me who I'm considering is a wolf. Seems a little odd he just randomly makes contact so late in the game and asks who I have suspicions on, the day I'm going to run for Mayor....

I didn't think that maybe the Wolf had already submitted the killing way before the lynch, maybe the length in time of making the killing last night was down to Drummy being late.

For that reason I'll be voting furiosum and DayumChris today.

JChalmers wrote:

DML wrote:

JChalmers wrote:Right cant be furiosum, he's not been on since half 8.

DML is the only one with a private profile and everyone else has been on all night since the lynch so why did it take this long for the wolf to confim their kill? Normally it's straight after the lynchl....

Firstly, I didn't even KNOW I HAD a private profile.

This line of reasoning doesn't make any sense. I'm know perhaps you haven't dealt with werewolves (I've dealt with whole packs of the buggers) but basically, they don't tend to wait til lynch time to lynch. They will lynch early, they will lynch late, anything to throw people off the scent. If I was a wolf, I'd be PMing my picks as soon as the candidates for Mayor were announced, why wait and get picked up on later. That would be a stupid tactic.

If this is a deflection tactic because you've been our wolf all along Chalmers, I'm not impressed. I've been the target and the scapegoat all along, and guess what Chalmers? IT ISN'T GOING TO WORK. If you ARE a villager (which I am increasingly starting to doubt) then you need to realise thats the case. Killing me now would be so, so stupid when we've ascertained through multiple sources I'm basically mathematically innocent. I was a 1 in 17 chance at best when we had the seered and unseered lists, and since then I have voted for 6 wolves in votes. My stories have matched up with everyone who has questioned me. If you think that is all one big ruse, then strawberry floating kill me. You'll be wrong.

The obvious targets are those who have never ever backed wolves to die, or have barely backed wolves to die. What wolf is going to back five or six people to die? It doesn't make any strawberry floating sense. They were WINNING the game as well, why would anyone need to do that?

Think I've got a bite

Tbh it was just a moment of chat me and PPM had last night before he was killed. We were saying about how the kill wasn't right away like normal and I was watching furiosum's profile to see if he was active. I mentioned to PPM you were private and he was going to do some digging but said if you were a wolf it would absolutely kill him I think I might've taken that a bit too literal for the game as he was suddenly found dead straight after haha.

I can assure you I am a villager, only been playing the game the second half as I was out travelling for work the first half.

I do have suspicions on DayumChris, he wasn't playing longer than me, then when I was thinking of running for Mayor he suddenly PMs me out of the blue and asks me who I'm considering is a wolf. Seems a little odd he just randomly makes contact so late in the game and asks who I have suspicions on, the day I'm going to run for Mayor....

I didn't think that maybe the Wolf had already submitted the killing way before the lynch, maybe the length in time of making the killing last night was down to Drummy being late.

For that reason I'll be voting furiosum and DayumChris today.

So you yourself say that I can't be the wolf because I wasn't online for the entirety of the wolf-kill period, and now you want to lynch me again?

Well I didn't consider DMLs theory that the Wolf had already submitted their vote earlier on in the day before the lynch even happened.

Furiosum's profile still says he was last active at 8:37 last night.

I'm not sure how the "Last Active" thing works, but it doesn't look like it's bullet proof evidence either way.

Maybe he was on then, put it as private to do his PM/Wolf Killing and has forgot to put it back to public before making that post.....

I'm not sure who will be voting for. Did think about furiosm and dml since they both voted for pancake when mini e put rik up but then both have ran for mayor with a wolf. And luke has vote for a.mayor with.jchalmers up for lynch so im really not sure. And yeah chalmers i wasnt really playing at the start i felt down and im only a villager anyway so i didnt bother much. When they put me for lynch with 4 others i didnt even bat an eyelid or notice until a day or 2 after cos i hadnt felt like playing. Even when i did come back to the game although the numbers of players had gone down their still like 100 pages to read up on. The only time ive been a wolf was dmls space.ayaw.and cos.it was my first ayaw an was doing really bad, my team sacrificed me.at the start by photoshoping a pm. They killed the seers 2 nights after because by then they had won the trust of a.circle. Sometines i wonder how random the roles are and if will get another.chance cos i did so bad last time.
Need more.time to decide about todays vote.

Dammit Chris, why are you writing like that?

It's like you're trying to play dumb. You don't normally write like that.

I'm not playing dumb, just posting what i think.

Remember that the deadline is 7pm and that you can change your votes any number of times you wish up until then.

I'm going to vote Furiosm for lynch because he was one of the people who voted for pacman which might have been to stop mini e coming into power lynching rik. Jay adama voted for Furiosm when he ran with ironhide so this could have been a sacrifice, not sure. :s

DML as the second person for the lynch, he claimed he was contacted by met a seer who as furiosm said was a newcomer so not sure how he got his email address? Also i'm suspicious of why DML is still alive when he announced in the thread he had been in contact with a seer?? He was also hidden only as he said it could have been from a previous game i suppose. Songwriter was almost inactive so might have been the perfect sacrifice if they had to make one. :s

I guess I can't prove I didn't temporarily go hidden for that period, although I've never made my profile hidden on this site or any other, and I'd like to think having drawn attention to it myself the last couple of days I wouldn't then bugger it up. I'm not sure what else I can say to defend myself that I haven't over the last day or so, but I'm happy to respond to any further allegations people might have against me. Regarding ironhide being a possible sacrifice, obviously I can't prove that he wasn't, but I would say that there was absolutely no suspicion at all on ironhide before I brought him up, indeed he was clearly a trusted villager since he was in at least one village trust group that I know of. If I was a wolf looking to make a sacrifice play, then I'd have strung up Luke, since he was more or less completely inactive at the time and thus a non-loss.

Anyway, as for potential wolves, I would be surprised if chris or jchalmers were wolves because they were so inactive for the early part of the game. Its not impossible that they were actively working with the wolves in the background, but I can't see why if that was the case they wouldn't be posting at least occasionally in the thread. Shadow would probably be my second choice if I had to pick one, but DML is absolutely my primary candidate. I've already explained my primary reasoning for suspecting him, and if he wants to question that I'm more than happy to reply.

Woah, I never said I was contacted specifically by Met, and I don't even know if it was directly a seer that contacted me. I'm itching for this game to end to find out who it was, but it certainly couldn't only be Met.

Thats a really daft reason to vote for me. Makes me pretty suspicious.

Yeah, met was only ever one of two seers. I don't know if pyschicsykes could have contacted DML via e-mail, it just seems unlikely that by a relatively late stage in the game sykes didn't have someone he was prepared to get info out through in a less bizarre way than an anonymous e-mail.