'Are You A Werewolf? - The Final Lynch? p374

I mentioned Krafty was suspect on day 2

Thanks for the work DML, but this was the worst one yet.

The main flaws were too many players, too many inactives (both wolves and humans) and the bridge thing lasted far too long (went on for 12 days from memory) - especially since you had to be here during the day which meant it was me/eight/denny/drummy pretty much everyday for about 9 days - especially when me/denny/drummy were pretty much all on the same page (because you'd look for the mayoral people first to check if wolves).

Thanks for the time/effort, especially doing it everyday for near 3 weeks, but can we just have a normal one next time?

Poncho wrote:I'm also happy to say that I am definitely not the worst vigilante ever. Mockmaster is still the defending champion.

Seriously though, being a vigilante is the WORST role in the whole game to have.

You actually posted the most useful thing in the entire game I found and that was the rules that you used for posting when you were a wolf, I'm not going to look that post up now but that was what helped me pile up the evidence on Comm Shep and initially on JK.

And for anyone interested in the Anti-Wolf Alliance that never was, here is what the full roster was to be...

Herb wrote:
Ocelot - Herb


Snake - Mocky


Naomi - Hexx


Drebin - Dumstick (Never sure if I can trust him)


The Colonel - Stu


Otacon - TAP


Sunny - aaronayl

We make our first approach tomorrow!

One thing I couldn't figure out was while Baron's plan was clever, why was he posting his seerings in the thread?

Poncho wrote:I'm also happy to say that I am definitely not the worst vigilante ever. Mockmaster is still the defending champion.

Seriously though, being a vigilante is the WORST role in the whole game to have.

Rest assured you upheld the epic lineage of really bad Vigilantes well, stretching all the way back to Jango. denster may be approaching my crown though with the taken out of Phantasmagorical.

Hexx wrote:I mentioned Krafty was suspect on day 2

Thanks for the work DML, but this was the worst one yet.

The main flaws were too many players, too many inactives (both wolves and humans) and the bridge thing lasted far too long (went on for 12 days from memory) - especially since you had to be here during the day which meant it was me/eight/denny/drummy pretty much everyday for about 9 days - especially when me/denny/drummy were pretty much all on the same page (because you'd look for the mayoral people first to check if wolves).

Thanks for the time/effort, especially doing it everyday for near 3 weeks, but can we just have a normal one next time?

Change your sig to the custom one.

I have thus decreed it so.

FatDaz wrote:

Poncho wrote:I'm also happy to say that I am definitely not the worst vigilante ever. Mockmaster is still the defending champion.

Seriously though, being a vigilante is the WORST role in the whole game to have.

surely bog standard human / villager is the worst.

Nope. Because being a vigilante, you are a still a villager but you've got the extra ability that means you can really make a difference. And it's all well and good saying "Stupid vigilante, you should save your bullets ", unless you've been one yourself, you have no idea how hard it is not to use them. You're a villager that can really make a difference and you really want to help out because you've the ability to do so.

It sucks I assure you.

Mockmaster wrote:

Poncho wrote:I'm also happy to say that I am definitely not the worst vigilante ever. Mockmaster is still the defending champion.

Seriously though, being a vigilante is the WORST role in the whole game to have.

Rest assured you upheld the epic lineage of really bad Vigilantes well, stretching all the way back to Jango. denster may be approaching my crown though with the taken out of Phantasmagorical.

The Parksey kill was better. He'd been nothing but helpful and posting stuff that the humans needed (really needed) yet for some reason it was taken as suspicous?!

I would just like to say how strawberry floated off with all the stupid inactive humans, they ruined this. THE last day that we could turn it around, I put myself completely out there to die, had two plans, both of which gave us a wolf. But due to the ridiculous amount of inactivity, it was easy for just 4 wolves to go for Memento as mayor.

Straight away after seeing his choices being mayor I knew he was a wolf, I probably should have come out and said this though

But HOW RETARDED ARE PEOPLE!!!??? Zartan was killed off, did people go for bridge wolf Clarkman? No. FatDaz was killed off after showing how Henke had set him up but everyone ignored Henke.

So I would just like to say this. strawberry float YOU INACTIVES. I have been at uni but got myself to the computer at least once a day, it did actually ruin it for the humans.

Edit : Rog and JK, well done, I had absolutely zero suspicions on you two.

Rog wrote:The Parksey kill was better. He'd been nothing but helpful and posting stuff that the humans needed (really needed) yet for some reason it was taken as suspicous?!

Ah yes, now you mention it, that kill seemed to make no sense at all.

Mockmaster wrote:

Rog wrote:The Parksey kill was better. He'd been nothing but helpful and posting stuff that the humans needed (really needed) yet for some reason it was taken as suspicous?!

Ah yes, now you mention it, that kill seemed to make no sense at all.

Very little did in this game.

Rog wrote:

Memento Mori wrote:

LewisD wrote:Now that it's over, there's something I'd like to mention:

DML wrote:

RULES

1a. All decisions based on who is what are totally RANDOM. And are not selected deliberately, and as such this should not influence your decision on who you think 'DML would select'.

Now look at this:

PLAYERS CURRENTLY IN -

Ship Psychic

The Baron Of Rhymes - SEER


Chief Doctor

Phantasmogorical - HERBALIST

Doesn't seem very "Random"....

I got Baron killed because I noticed that.

Clarkman noticed that Baron was writing in green, which he usually doesn't. That's why I sent the baron death into DML. My original PM that day had mcihgje2 in his place but I changed my mind.

Mayne, you wanted me killed, i thought we were blood. Seriously though i had done strawberry float all in this thread so why did you want to kill me?

mcjihge2 wrote:

Rog wrote:

Memento Mori wrote:

LewisD wrote:Now that it's over, there's something I'd like to mention:

DML wrote:

RULES

1a. All decisions based on who is what are totally RANDOM. And are not selected deliberately, and as such this should not influence your decision on who you think 'DML would select'.

Now look at this:

PLAYERS CURRENTLY IN -

Ship Psychic

The Baron Of Rhymes - SEER


Chief Doctor

Phantasmogorical - HERBALIST

Doesn't seem very "Random"....

I got Baron killed because I noticed that.

Clarkman noticed that Baron was writing in green, which he usually doesn't. That's why I sent the baron death into DML. My original PM that day had mcihgje2 in his place but I changed my mind.

Mayne, you wanted me killed, i thought we were blood. Seriously though i had done strawberry float all in this thread so why did you want to kill me?

Actually, you were another clever bastard. Shame two of you weren't around at the same time really. I wanted you offed the day before but got told it would look suspicious.

Rog wrote:One thing I couldn't figure out was while Baron's plan was clever, why was he posting his seerings in the thread?

To be clever. I thought the way he did it was bloody genius.

Herb wrote:
You actually posted the most useful thing in the entire game I found and that was the rules that you used for posting when you were a wolf, I'm not going to look that post up now but that was what helped me pile up the evidence on Comm Shep and initially on JK.

It's obviously not full-proof, but you can guarantee that at least one or two wolves will adopt this posting habit in every single game. And in the context of the game, it's a lot go on. That post I made, then posted again for emphasis is why I thought I might be killed very soon as in my eyes, my posts on wolf behaviour pretty much cemented my status as a villager.

But yeah, next time keep the game a lot more simpler and keep it smaller. It'll be much better for it.

MCN wrote:

Rog wrote:One thing I couldn't figure out was while Baron's plan was clever, why was he posting his seerings in the thread?

To be clever. I thought the way he did it was bloody genius.

Yeah it was genius but posting it for everyone to see was a little odd.

I'd like to extend my thanks to DML for taking so much of his own time to put all this together and run it. It was my first ever game of AYAW, and it certainly won't be my last.

As for people posting after death, we pretty much had to, simply to keep the thread going.

Oh, and Nood is off my christmas card list for killing me. The bastard.

Hold on, didn't one of the Baron's poems say Henke was a human?

MCN wrote:

Rog wrote:One thing I couldn't figure out was while Baron's plan was clever, why was he posting his seerings in the thread?

To be clever. I thought the way he did it was bloody genius.

Agreed, Nobody knew what the hell he was doing until MCN pointed it out.

I think the problem was, all the best players/humans we could of had got killed off in the first few days by the wolves. Which left us with about 20 or so inactive humans and barely any active ones. Well done to the wolves though, especially near the end, there was no way we could of got a human mayor.

mcjihge2 wrote:

Rog wrote:

Memento Mori wrote:

LewisD wrote:Now that it's over, there's something I'd like to mention:

DML wrote:

RULES

1a. All decisions based on who is what are totally RANDOM. And are not selected deliberately, and as such this should not influence your decision on who you think 'DML would select'.

Now look at this:

PLAYERS CURRENTLY IN -

Ship Psychic

The Baron Of Rhymes - SEER


Chief Doctor

Phantasmogorical - HERBALIST

Doesn't seem very "Random"....

I got Baron killed because I noticed that.

Clarkman noticed that Baron was writing in green, which he usually doesn't. That's why I sent the baron death into DML. My original PM that day had mcihgje2 in his place but I changed my mind.

Mayne, you wanted me killed, i thought we were blood. Seriously though i had done strawberry float all in this thread so why did you want to kill me?

After your initial stumble you started to get wise. So you had to die. It was nothing personal. And thanks for compiling the list of Baron's seers for us

So who ordered my death?