And finally some explanations on the slight muck up with the player list and why I didn’t think it was gamebreaking.
I was stupid and after I randomly assigned roles I ordered my spreadsheet into an alphabetical by role order. This made it easier for me to see who was a vigi, who was a seer etc. Of course I then copied and pasted that into the OP without even thinking.
I was thinking about pretending that was deliberate and was designed just to mess around with people, but I don’t think I am a good enough liar to get away with that.
However, this game was always going to result in the special roles being revealed and with them being picked off by the infected. This was part of the idea behind the game, the fact that trust circles could form but that they would eventually be broken and the infected would soon know who they all were. This (unfortunately!) happened a lot earlier than I thought it was going to and had the crappy result of Ironhide being exposed which was the main problem when the player list was revealed. Of course the other problem was that the alphabetical list also exposed Errkal, who was right there near the top.
I decided that the best way to handle things was to tell the truth, while also bullshitting you all. As Ironhide died, I announced that there was a new Alpha and made clear that this new Alpha was a random pick. He was a random pick, it’s just the random pick was chosen at the start of the game, not when Ironhide died.
So that’s what happened, I did bad but there wasn’t any real need (imo!) to restart the game or randomise the roles again. Indeed that would have been worse as everyone would have known the exact roles that were there, what was in the vials etc etc. And I wasn’t going to risk not ever exposing MechaPutin to the world.
I hope everyone enjoyed it (despite the strawberry float ups!) and that nobody feels like I was making things up as I went along once Ironhide died.
I enjoyed running the game but it is a hell of a lot more work than I ever expected! And I cut some of the work down with things like making the leaders choose who to lynch rather than a PM vote etc. Fun, but time consuming!