Day Zero
Cheeky Devlin was found dead in the cave.
Day One
EVENTS
Psychicsykes was made the very first Captain.
He elected to stick Ecno and Fatal Exception into the brig.
Fatal Exception was lynched via plank walking - he was a HUMAN.
The dig provided no results.
JV, Mini E and Jango were all killed at night - all were HUMANS.
Very late at night - DBlock was found dead - definitely shot. He was a HUMAN also.
IDEAS – Lynching inactives
For – denster (H), Deadpool (H), Mori (H), Rog (H), StayDead (H), Skippy (V), Rog (H) Roonmastor (S), Red Devil, HM
Against – TAP, Cuttooth, PCCD, Henke (H), Shafto, Drawlight, mcjihge2 (H), DaLax (at least, says players are inactive for a reason)
IDEAS – Looking at people PMing
For – Sykes (H), Mori (H), DangChris
Against – Nood, Rog (H), TAP
IDEAS – Lynching TroublemakersFor - TAP, Cuttooth, PCCD, Drumstick, DD64, Poncho (H), Drawlight
Against – StayDead (H), Aneurin, Henke (H), Gorrable
SUSPICIONS/LYNCHING IDEAS
Nood and Bork jokingly accuse each other.
Poncho (H) says lynch Herbi (H).
Aneurin labelled Argo, Clarkman, Henke (H), Herbi (H) and StayDead (H) “troublemakers”
DangChris thinks Ecno (FW) is a wolf
Poncho (H) says look at Ecno (FW)
AJ Styles and Cuttooth say Ecno (FW)/StayDead (H)
StayDead (H) suspects G-Rat (H)
StayDead (H) thinks G-Rat (H), Aaron (M), Cuttooth, AJ Styles and Aneurin are against him
Drumstick thinks Ecno (FW) is our best lead
Cuttooth wants Ecno (FW) jailed
Drumstick thinks Ecno is a cert if he is the general consensus’ pick
Aneurin winds StayDead (H) up, both argue
Aaron (M) thinks StayDead (H) should go
Nood wants Herbi (H) dead
JK says Drawlight’s posts are “characteristically great”
JK says he will support any lynching of Ecno (FW), Herbi, FE and Staydead (all H)
Rog (H) wants Staydead (H) and an inactive
HM will vote Mori (H) as long as the second lynchee is Aaron (M)
HM says he will be inactive until next Tuesday
JK is not voting for any mayor, perhaps still in love with Drawlight
BigCheez will echo want HM says about lynching Aaron
PCCD wants Aaron (M) as the second guy
TAP is not suspicious of anyone, has missed entire thread up to this point due to uni all day
TAP strongly against using Mori’s PM evidence, thinks he should be directly responsible if they die
Hyperion agrees with this
Shafto suspects Aaron (M)
Supporting People for Mayor and their pledges
Bork puts Mori (H) forward for his PM ideas, presumably
Drumstick puts himself forward, lynching troublemakers via a vote
Sykes (H) supports an Ecno(FW) or Fatal Exception (H) lynch
Mori (H) – FE (H) and general consensus
DD64 wants a general consensus
Shafto agrees with Ecno (FW) and FE (H)
Sykes (H) say he will go in with Ecno (FW) and Mori (H)
BigCheez can see logic in FE (H) but leaning towards Mori (H), sits on fence a bit
Denster (H) will go with general consensus
Skippy (V) wants Ecno (FW) alive
Drawlight thinks Sykes (H) is our best bet, would put in Ecno (FW), FE (H)
Drawlight would also be happy with StayDead (H) and Herbi (H)
Luke_25 wants Ecno (FW) lynched
G-rat (H) says Ecno (FW)
Mocky says Ecno (FW) and one of Herbi (H) and StayDead (H)
StayDead (H) says Herbi (H) and Ecno (FW)
Rog (H) says StayDead (H) and an inactive
Skippy (V) puts his hat in the ring – lynching FE (H) and Herbi (H)
StayDead (H) – lynching Aaron (M) and Ecno (FW)
Aneurin retracts his candidacy, gets absolutely no votes for mayor
Skippy (V) pulls out of race, had Nood as his solitary vote
StayDead (H) pulls out, has no votes anyway
Gorrable votes Sykes (H) but thinks neither of his nominations are wolves
Hyperion wants Aneurin and Wiggles (H) lynched
Drawlight strongly wants FE (H) as the second choice, JK swoons
Shafto says he will go for mayor tomorrow, with Mori (H) and Aaron (M)
Drawlight thinks the StayDead (H) case is a fuss over nothing
Mayoral Votes as they happen
Deadpool (H) votes Sykes (H)
Cuttooth votes Sykes (H)
DangChris votes Sykes (H)
G-Rat (H) votes Sykes (H)
BIDO votes Sykes (H)
Nood votes Skippy (V)
Drawlight votes Mori (H)
Drumstick votes Sykes (H)
Aneurin withdraws, votes Sykes (H)
Skippy (V) withdraws, votes Sykes (H)
Oblomov votes Sykes (H)
Frank (H) votes Sykes (H)
Dala votes Sykes (H)
Shafto votes Sykes (H)
Gorrable votes Sykes (H)
Karlprof votes Sykes (H)
Red (H) votes Sykes (H)
Mcjihge2 (H) votes Mori (H)
Pxyl-8 votes Sykes (H)
Bigcheez votes Sykes (H)
Wiggles (H) votes Mori (H)
PCCD votes Mori (H)
Skippy (V) changes vote to Mori (H)
Aneurin changes vote to Mori (H)
Caliban votes Sykes (H)
Final Mayoral Vote
PsychicSykes - Jailing Ecno and Fatal Exception (16)
Cuttooth, BID0, Deadpool (H), Drumstick, DangChris, Oblomov Boblomov, Frank (H), Dalagonash, StayDead (H), Shafto, Gorrable, Karlprof, Red (H), bigcheez2k3, pyxl-8, Caliban
Memento Mori - Jailing Fatal Exception and Aaron/Herbi (8)
Drawlight, The Master, mcjihge2 (H), PCCD, Skippy (V), á, Wiggles (H), HM
Lynching votes revealed in thread
Luke_25 says he voted Ecno (FW)
KP voted FE (H)
PCCD says he voted for “insert generic candidate” for “insert generic reason”
D Block (H) votes Ecno (FW)
Shafto votes for Ecno (FW)
Smurphy votes Ecno (FW)
Drawlight votes FE (H)
Denster (H) votes Ecno (FW)
Post D1 Lynch, Pre D1-Kill
Melatonin reveals he voted FE (H) after the result is announced
Zeni thinks Mori (H) is not to be blamed
Benj (H) thinks people should not be lynched on crazy accusations
Day Two
Skippy was sworn in as Captain of the Arcadia.
Shafto and Herbi were put into prison.
Songwriter was made immune for two days due to a IRL health scare - we all wish him well.
Herbi was lynched. He was a HUMAN.
No results came from the dig.
Ars Moriendi, Diabolito and Hulohot all met a grizzly end on the beach.
IDEAS – Against “General Consensus/Random” voting
For – StayDead (H), Parksey, denster (H), Mockmaster, HM, Pedz (H), Sykes (H), DaLax, Drumstick
Against – Cuttooth (random number generator), G-Rat (H), JK, Hyperion, Oblomov, Aaron (M), Poncho (H)
General Suspicions/Accusations
Zeni thinks Herbi (H) and Shafto are worth looking at
PCCD suspects Aaron (M)
BIDO suspects Aaron (M), Herbi (H) and Shafto
Clarkman (H) says wolves will vote late in elections
Clarkman (H) says that wolves will not run for mayor this early, due to humans putting humans up
Hyperion argues quite heavily for random selection, a few now-known humans warm to the idea
Poncho (H) thinks wolves will not like the random selection
Hyperion thinks PCCD, Denster (H), Songwriter, Aaron (M), G-rat (H), Frank (H), Pedz (H), Skippy (V), Satriales, Rog (H), Drumstick, Bork, Mori (H) and AJ Styles are suspicious.
Poncho (H) – Nood, pxyl, Stu, Roon (S), KP, Herbi (H), Rog (H), satriales (H), Drumstick, Bork, Deadpool(H)
Melatonin is fine with Herbi (H) and Shafto
Mocky – Satriales (H), Karlprof, Look over There, Dala, Superking, DD64, smurphy amongst confirmed (Hs)
Oblomov says Frank (H), Nova (H) , Ario (H) and Hulohot (H) jump out from Mocky’s list
DangChris wants Argonaut (H) lynched
Cuttooth thinks definitely Frank (H)
Hyperion thinks Ario (H), Frank (H), Ars Morendi (H) and Karlprof from Mocky’s list
Luke thinks Ario (H), Baron Zemo (H) and Karlprof, Dala and Smurphy
Henke says Mocky has the right idea with his list
StayDead (H) rants against Oblomov, Hyperion and Aneurin
Mayoral Support/Mayor Runs
Shafto says he will run for mayor – Aaron (M) and Mori (H)
Skippy (V) says he will run for mayor – Aaron (M) and one other by consensus
Cuttooth will run with Herbi (H) and a random number generator
Henke (H) votes for Skippy (V) to get rid of Shafto
JK will run with two random players
Poncho (H) votes Skippy (V) on the basis he will not put Aaron (M) in
Votes for Mayor as they Happened
PCCD votes Shafto
Irene (H) votes Cuttooth
G-Rat (H) votes Cuttooth
Henke (H) votes Skippy (V)
Zeni votes Skippy (V)
Aaron (M) votes Cuttooth
Hank (S) votes Cuttooth
Gorrable votes Skippy (V)
BIDO votes Skippy (V)
Mori (H) votes Skippy (V)
Wiggles (H) votes Skippy (V)
Drawlight votes Skippy (V)
Benj (H) votes JK
Denster votes Skippy (V)
Mcjihge2 (H) votes Cuttooth
Drumstick votes Skippy (V)
TAP votes Skippy (V)
Poncho (H) votes Skippy (V)
StayDead (H) votes Skippy (V)
Nova (H) votes Skippy (V)
Nood votes Skippy (V)
Pedz (H) votes Skippy (V)
Red (H) votes Skippy (V)
Final Mayoral Vote
Shafto – Mori (H) and Aaron (M) (2)
PCCD, Red Devil
Skippy (V) – Herbi (H) and Shafto (16)
Henke (H), Deadpool (H), Zenigame, Gorrable, BID0, Memento Mori (H), Wiggles (H), Drawlight, Drummy, Denster (H), TAP, Staydead (H), Nova (H), The Master, Pedz (H), Red (H)
Cuttooth – Herbi (H) and Randomly Drawn Player (6)
Irene (H), G-rat (H), Hank (S), Aaron (M), mcjihge2 (H), á
JK - Two Randomly Drawn Players (1)
Benj (H)
Votes revealed in-thread
Nood votes Herbi (H)
Bork probably voting Herbi (H)
Wiggles (H) votes Herbi (H)
Hyperion votes Shafto
DangChris votes Herbi (H)
BIDO probably voting Herbi (H)
Satriales (H) votes Herbi (H)*
Parksey votes Herbi (H)
Kanbei votes Herbi (H)
*accidently posts vote in thread and doesn’t realise
Post Kill, Pre Lynch
Gorrable says Satriales (H), Frank (H) and Diabolito (H) have posted since Mocky’s list was put up
Cuttooth says Ario (H), Frank (H), Satriales (H), DaLax, smurphy, diabolito (H) have posted
Day Three
Oblomov Boblomov was made Captain for a day.
Ario and Frank were quickly sent to the brig.
The dig of C1 - yet again - no results.
Ario was chosen to be lynched. He was a HUMAN.
Aaronayl1, Pedz and Zartan were found horribly killed. Aaron was a MERCHANT, and the others were normal HUMANS.
IDEAS – Rog(H) and/or StayDead(H) lynchingFor – Aneurin, Zenigame, , Skippy (V),
Against – Poncho (H), Mori (H), Drumstick, Ecno (FW), Oblomov, Wiggles (H), Mocky, Kanbei, Sykes (H)
General Suspicions
Everyone gets a PM from Argonaut (H), everyone suspects him.
Call and Answer is a touch suspicious of Hyperion
Deadpool (H) raises some slight suspicions about Drumstick
DangChris thinks Argonaut (H) is a wolf still
Clarkman (H) thinks DangChris is posting like a wolf – that wolf being DangChris in a previous game
TAP says he will be away all weekend and may be AWOL. Still posts regularly
Drumstick thinks Rog (H) has mislead StayDead (H) and Nova (H) is suspicious
Poncho (H) thinks StayDead(H) being lynched is a dead-end
Drummy and Mori (H) think lynching StayDead(H) is a waste of time
Ecno (FW) and Oblomov think StayDead (H) is not a wolf
So do Wiggles (H) and Mocky
Mocky thinks Oblomov and PCCD
Kanbei and Sykes (H) don’t think StayDead (H) is a wolf
Rog (H) thinks StayDead (H) is better out of the game
Poncho (H) says look at those wanting StayDead (H) out
Clarkman (H) suspects G-Rat (H), Red (H), Mori (H) and Dala
Mayoral Support and Pledges
Aneurin stands – StayDead(H)/other by consensus
Oblomov looks to stand – Frank (H) and Ario (H)
StayDead (H) – Aneurin and Hyperion
PCCD – Smurphy and Look Over There
Deadpool (H) – Argonaut (H) and Hyperion
Deadpool (H) withdraws
Drumstick will support a Nova (H) and Rog (H) mayor
Mori (H) wants Nova (H) and Ario (H) in
Zeni thinks Argonaut (H) and StayDead(H)
Smurphy thinks Aneurin’s candidate should be Nova (H)
BIDO wants Nova (H) and Hyperion up
Deadpool thinks of switching votes
Zeni will swap to Oblomov if he puts Hank (S) in instead of Frank (H)
Nood, Gorrable and Red Devil all vote OB within 2 minutes of each other, putting him one behind Aneurin
Votes as they happened
Melatonin votes Aneurin
Frank (H) votes Aneurin
BigCheez votes Aneurin
Deadpool (H) votes Aneurin
Smurphy votes Aneurin
DD64 votes Oblomov
Skippy (V) votes Aneurin
Denster (H) votes Aneurin
Mori (H) votes Oblomov
Sykes (H) votes Oblomov
Ario (H) votes Aneurin
Pxyl votes Aneurin
Mcjhige2 (H) votes Oblomov
Nood votes Oblomov
Gorrable votes Oblomov
Red Devil votes Oblomov
PCCD drops out, votes Oblomov
Deadpool (H) switches to Oblomov
Ecno (FW) votes Oblomov
Final Mayoral Vote
á StayDead (H) and One by consensus (provisionally Drumstick) (7)
Melatonin, Frank (H), bigcheez2k3, Skippy (V), Denster (H), Zenigame, pyxl-8
Oblomov Boblomov Frank (H) and Ario (H) (10)
Dark Dragon 64, Mori (H), PsychicSykes (H), mcjihge2 (H), The Master, Gorrable, RD, PCCD, Deadpool (H), Ecno (FW)
StayDead (H) á and Hyperion (0)
Votes revealed in thread
Zeni probably voting Ario (H)
BIDO votes Ario (H)
Pedz (H) votes Ario (H)
Ecno (FW) votes Frank (H)
Zeni votes Ario (H)
Gorrable votes Ario (H)
Irene (H) votes Ario (H)
Luke votes Ario (H)
Bork votes Frank (H)
Drumstick votes Ario (H)
Satriales (H), StayDead (H) and Shafto all flip coins
Post Kill, Pre Lynch
Shafto thinks Oblomov, Sykes (H) and Skippy (V) should be held to account
Day Four -
StayDead died in unknown circumstances. He was HUMAN.
Argonaut was made El Capitan.
He stuck Melatonin and Roonmastor in the slammer.
Songwriter's immunity ended.
The dig found a blue serpent chest.
Denster was shot. He was a HUMAN.
Roonmastor - A SEER was lynched.
Found dead were Wiggles, Irene Demova and Hank Scorpio. Wiggles and Irene Humans - Hank the second SEER.
G-Rat was mysteriously shot. He was a HUMAN.
General Suspicions
HM thinks the wolves knew about Aaron (M)
Wiggles (H) says don’t assume this was the case
Drawlight thinks the wolves did know, as why kill a player some suspected?
Argonaut posts the results of his PM investigation
Roonmastor thinks Aaron (M) talked to G-Rat (H)
Poncho (H) notices Bigcheez in the topic without posting for agggges
Dala sits on the fence with regard to Argonaut (H)
Shafto thinks Argonaut’s (H) PM investigation is “nice work”
Denster (H) thinks voting Argonaut (H) in is asking for trouble
Luke suspects DD64
Mori (H) thinks Melatonin is posting like a classic wolf
Mocky finds melatonin’s run for captain at odds with his normal post style
Aneurin claims he attacked StayDead (H) to draw wolves out in support
Aneurin suspects Melatonin
JK suspects G-Rat (H) due to Aaron’s (M) death
JK also suspects Frank (H) and melatonin
Gorrable agrees with this from JK
Aneurin believes there is something fishy about his lost election yesterday
Melly says he can clear his name using “The fundamentals of how the game runs”
Poncho (H) says we should look at semi-inactives like Stu
Henke (H) feels there at least three wolves about the mayoral voters, but that they won’t have blocked voted
Gorrable feels we need to remember this vote if someone comes out about melatonin, Poncho (H), G-Rat (H), Roon (S), Argonaut (H),
Roon mentions that he was PMing other players for mayoral support
Sykes (H) strongly suspects Roon (S) and advises us to lynch him
Mayoral Support and Pledges
Staydead (H) says he’ll run with Oblomov and Hyperion
Argonaut (H) – Drumstick, Satriales (H), Sykes (H) and Deadpool (H)
Shafto – Sykes (H), Skippy (V), Oblomov
Melatonin – StayDead (H) and one by consensus
Roonmastor – G-Rat (H) and one by consensus
Poncho runs, pending manifesto
PCCD – Shafto and Poncho (H)
Pxyl would back a manifesto that lynches Argonaut (H)
Satriales (H) – Argonaut (H) and general consensus
Benj (H) says Argo (H) should remove Drumstick from his list
AJ says he is voting for StayDead (H)
Roon (S) decides his other lynchee is Argonaut (H)
Frank (H) says if Melatonin changes StayDead (H) to Mori (H) he will vote for him
Gorrable says he will consider switching his vote to Poncho (H) if he makes a good case
Poncho (H) runs with Melly and Stu
Luke says he will run with smurphy and bigcheez up
Poncho (H) and Mockmaster feel that today’s election is “intense” and important (when Melly withdraws)
Luke feels that Roon (S) has the backing of the wolves in this election.
Aneurin reckons the swing towards Poncho (H) is disturbing
G-rat (H) and Poncho (H) reiterate that this is a very important election
Drummy doesn’t trust Argo (H)
JK abstains from the vote, unless it is a dead heat as both candidates are suspicious
Satriales (H) switches votes as he thinks Drumstick is following him, for whatever reason
Roon (S) feels his defeat is a pivotal moment
Melly feels that he is up purely on gut feeling, and that this is dangerous
Melatonin also thinks him signing up late means that he was just a human bolted on at the end
Benj (H) says he never switched votes and Cuttooth has him down incorrectly; Cutty says he took a post the wrong way
Argo (H) says Melatonin was in to make up the numbers and get voters from Poncho (H)
Red Devil jokingly says he is voting for melatonin
Votes as they happened
AJ votes StayDead (H)
G-Rat (H) votes Argo (H)
Aneurin votes Argo (H)
Deadpool (H) votes Roonmastor (S)
Shafto votes Argo (H)
Dala votes Roon (S)
Satriales (H) votes Roon (S)
DD64 votes Roon (S)
Pxyl votes Roon (S)
Denster (H) votes Roon (S)
Drawlight votes Roon (S)
Benj (H) votes Roon (S)
Cuttooth votes Roon (S)
G-Rat (H) votes Argo (H)
Drumstick votes Roon (S)
Mcjihge2 (H) votes Argo (H)
Gorrable votes Argo (H)
Oblomov votes Poncho (H)
Mori (H) votes Poncho (H)
Sykes (H) votes Poncho (H)
Luke votes Poncho (H)
Karlprof votes Roon (S)
Bork votes Poncho (H)
Henke (H) votes Argo (H)
Ecno (FW) votes Roon (S)
Aneurin switches, votes Poncho (H)
Melatonin withdraws, votes Roon (S)
Oblomov switches from Poncho (H) to Argo (H)
Cuttooth switches to Argo (H)
Bork switches to Argo (H)
Luke switches to Argo (H)
Aneurin switches, votes Argo (H)
Poncho officially drops out, votes Argo (H)
HM votes Argo (H) *2:29pm, with vote 13-12 to Roon(S)*
Wiggles (H) votes Argo (H)
Kanbei votes Argo (H)
Mori (H) switches to Argo (H)
Satriales (H) switches to Argo (H)
Drumstick switches to Argo (H) 2:48pm 18-11 to Argo
Satriales (H) switches back to Roon (S)
BIDO votes Roon (S) at 3pm
Final Mayoral Vote
Argonaut(H) - Melatonin and Roonmastor (S) (18)
Shafto, mcjihge2 (H), G-Rat (H), Gorrable, Henke (H), PsychicSykes (H), Mind Crime, Cuttooth, bork, Luke_25, á, Poncho (H), HM, Wiggles (H), Kanbei, Mori (H), Satriales (H), Drumstick
Roonmastor (S) - G-Rat (H) and Argonaut (H), (12)
Deadpool (H), Dalagonash, Dark Dragon 64, pyxl-8, Denster (H), Drawlight, Benj (H), bigcheez2k3, Ecno (FW), Karlprof, melatonin, BID0
Poncho (H) (withdrawn) - Melatonin and Stu (1)
Red (H)
Before Poncho dropped out
Argonaut (H) - Melatonin and Roonmastor (S) (6)
Shafto, mcjihge2(H), G-Rat (H), Gorrable, Henke (H), PsychicSykes (H)
Roonmastor (S) - G-rat (H) and Argonaut (H)
Deadpool(H), Satriales (H), Dalagonash, Dark Dragon 64, pyxl-8, Denster (H), Drawlight, Benj (H), Cuttooth, Drumstick, bigcheez2k3, Ecno (FW), Karlprof, melatonin
Poncho (H)- Melatonin and Stu (6)
Mind Crime, Memento Mori (H), Luke_25, bork, á, Red (H)
Votes revealed in thread
Pxyl votes Melatonin
Satriales (H) votes Roon (S)
Hyperion says he is unsure
Luke votes melatonin
After lynch…
Benj (H) voted Roon (S)
Parksey voted Roon (S)
Cuttooth voted Roon (S)
Red Devil voted Melatonin
Drawlight voted melatonin
Mockmaster voted melatonin
Mori voted melatonin
Drumstick voted melatonin
Post Lynch Pre Kill
Look over There doesn’t trust “this Argonaut (H) fellow”
PCCD will put Argonaut (H) and G-rat (H) in “for definite”
Five minutes later, PCCD will put Argonaut (H) and Sykes (H) in
Look Over There says he will run, G-rat (H) and Argonaut (H)
Five minutes later, PCCD will put in G-rat (H) and Argonaut (H)
Melly asks if we have a captain to lynch G-rat (H) and Argonaut (H); clearly can’t read
Call and Answer thinks Sykes (H) shouldn’t be forgotten for his anti-Roon (S) stance
Shafto wants G-rat (H) and Argonaut (H) out the way