'Arrrrr You A Werewolf?' - Wolves Attack - 11pm

Last edited by Cuttooth on Thu Nov 11, 2010 4:05 pm, edited 1 time in total.

It is a good idea to not kill melatonin on the possibility that he is protecting Alpha Gorrable and isn't doing a mocking "You can't kill us all you know

".

Or is a piece of gooseberry fool human messing about. We can kill him tomorrow regardless. I'm dropping out of the race and voting for de facto smurphy.

EDIT - Just realised it's way past the 3pm deadline anyway.

No. We kill melatonin. We can get Gorrable tomorrow.

pyxl-8 wrote:No. We kill melatonin. We can get Gorrable tomorrow.

Bingo.

We have to get the wolf kills down to 2.

Yep, go for Melly.

Kanbei wrote:
pyxl-8 wrote:No. We kill melatonin. We can get Gorrable tomorrow.

Bingo.

We have to get the wolf kills down to 2.

Surely it's worth the risk in order to possibly get the wolf kills not only down to 1, but to also have no kills tonight? Worst case scenario is we lose one extra player than we would have done tonight and then lynch Melatonin tomorrow. Have a look at Gorrable's posts in the thread and tell me they're not incredibly suspicious.

Actually, you're right. If Gorrable was the Alpha and melly a wolf then they'd only be able to kill two people over the next two nights no matter who was killed first. melatonin could always be doing some elaborate double bluff.

Yeah, melatonin dies tonight.

Cuttooth wrote:Actually, you're right. If Gorrable was the Alpha and melly a wolf then they'd only be able to kill two people over the next two nights no matter who was killed first. melatonin could always be doing some elaborate double bluff.

That's not true. They would kill no one tonight and then have to only kill one from then on!

Does killing the Alpha drop the kills by one as well as giving us a night of immunity?

Yes.

Edit - no, it drops the kills to one.

Oh gooseberry fool, seriously? Hmm...

Can't we just kill them both? :shifty:

Lynch Melatonin

Best case scenario - lynch a wolf; wolves down to two kills per night
Worst case scenario - Melatonin's strawberry floating around; wolves carry on with three kills

Lynch Gorrable

Best case scenario - lynch the Alpha; wolves can't kill tonight and are down to one kill per night
Worst case scenario - lynch a human; wolves carry on with three kills; lynch Melatonin tomorrow
Other possible outcome - lynch a regular wolf; wolves down to two kills per night

á wrote:
pyxl-8 wrote:No. We kill melatonin. We can get Gorrable tomorrow.

Agree.

We've wasted too many days following people that have over-thought proposals and wound up accusing proactive humans of being wolves.

DaLax and smurphy, as our only confirmed humans, must take turns as mayor for their own safety. Surely nobody can seriously argue that either of them are wolves.

Red Devil wrote:Yeah. Sorry about that. EVeryone seemed dead certain Henke was a wolf.

Oh herro.

I'll likely vote to Lynch Gorrable. Mind Crime sums it up very well.

I can't believe this discussion is even happening, theres a FAR greater chance that Melly is a wolf than there is Gorrable being the Alpha. We need to vote with our heads not with our hearts.

The worst possible thing that could happen if we lynch Gorrable tonight (unless he's some sort of crazy human special ability character that we aren't aware of) is that we lose one extra human. Are you telling me it's not worth that single sacrifice in order to attempt to lynch the Alpha?

Like I said, time is of the essence. Maybe that one extra human would be the one that makes the difference at the end, but I doubt it. I feel that we need to gamble.

Oblomov Boblomov wrote:The worst possible thing that could happen if we lynch Gorrable tonight (unless he's some sort of crazy human special ability character that we aren't aware of) is that we lose one extra human. Are you telling me it's not worth that single sacrifice in order to attempt to lynch the Alpha?

Like I said, time is of the essence. Maybe that one extra human would be the one that makes the difference at the end, but I doubt it. I feel that we need to gamble.

There's 30 humans left! We need to hold on as long as we can! Seriously we can lynch Gorrable tomorrow (nothing at all against that) but i'd much rather have the wolves down to 2 kills as soon as possible, in case there are any other special roles out there.

Okay, well I guess people can vote for whatever they think is best, as either way both will probably be dead after tomorrow.

Bloody hell, interesting turn of events. Look guys. Take hold of your senses. Eyes on the prize. We finally have an admitted wolf. It is melatonin. Lynch the strawberry floater back to kingdom come and we officially begin the fightback today. We need every single vote. Do you honestly think melatonin would pretend to be a wolf for a laugh and screw the humans over? That is a bonkers theory that is so high def it is ridiculous. We can look at Gorrable tomorrow but for now I tend to agree with Kanbei.

If melatonin is definitely a wolf, then it's best to get them down to two kills as soon as possible rather than take a massive risk with the Alpha, I feel. All we have to go on with that is general suspicion.

The only risk with melatonin is that he may just be a human bored of playing and staring at the prospect of defeat, and seeing how easy we all are to lead on by saying he needs to be lynched. That's the only reason I can think of why a human would pretend to be a wolf while in jail.

If melatonin is a wolf, we mustn't let our attention get diverted away from Gorrable though, if we pledge to kill him tomorrow. People may start distraction tactics, bring up old stuff or start going back through melly's posts.

'Arrrrr You A Werewolf?' - Wolves Attack - 11pm

Who is online

Affiliates