339 Dan.s until Christmas! wrote:This, and 'Herbi was the Alpha' are two pre-GRcade events, aren't they? So there's no thread to go back to - for those of us that weren't there, we hear these things referred to all the time, but we don't know exactly what they mean. Were Bladeforce the original secret circle, then? And was Herbi the alpha? Or no?
A very loose history:
Herbi’s the strawberry floating Alpha: It’s AYAW III on the old Future-run GamesRadar forum. It’s about 7 days in and the status of the game (from memory) is as follows. Team Villager started with 3 seers who incredibly had managed to find one other via seering (petercrisp, TAP, Roonmastor). As a result they co-ordinated their nightly inspections, however, before finding one another, they all had a common suspicion of one player: Herbi. This was largely in part down to Herbi’s reputation at the time in respect of how he played the game. That is to say that he played in a pretty outlandish and overzealous way, posting things which could be readily disproved by a number of people and also posting a lot of blatant lies. So then, the existing suspicion on him was only compounded when werewolf JimmyInAShed sent a screenshot of something (I don’t recall what) to someone who happened to be in this seer alliance (but who wasn’t a seer) and his taskbar showed he was in an MSN conversation with myself (werewolf) and someone whose MSN name begun with ‘The Go’ with the rest being obscured. Herbi’s MSN name at the time was ‘The Good’.
However, Herbi had already been seered and came back as a villager. Taking a punt, the seers decided to seer Jimmy. He came back as a Werewolf. Naturally this led the seers to believe that their instincts could be right after all and that Herbi could actually be a werewolf, but if this was to be true he would have to be The Alpha. The next day the seers needed someone who was electable as Mayor to stick Herbi in the noose. I don’t remember who they got to do it but for whatever reason, Hexx, another player who was under massive amounts of suspicion was imprisoned as well. The lynch vote ending up being a tie (and for this vote there was a twist that the votes would be made public after). Herbi ended up, IIRC, making up some lie about Hexx which saved him on the re-vote. Us werewolves were thrilled about this because it meant that the biggest distraction in the game lived on for another day.
The next day, knowing that the thread needed a wolf kill to lift morale after a week of misses, the fact that Jimmy had been seered as a wolf was leaked out. He was subsequently lynched and the villagers celebrated. I was totally unaware at this time that the aforementioned screenshot existed and rather unfortunately I was seered that night and killed the following day. So, to recap, thanks to this screenshot, two wolves had been killed in two days and the seer network were 100% utterly and totally convinced that they’d identified the Alpha. After I died, Corazon and I were chatting on MSN as we had been throughout the game. Obviously I wasn’t going to confirm or deny anything that he may have suspected about my wolfy comrades but I was certainly curious to know what he thought about other players in the game. So we went through a few people, I reeled off some names and eventually I got to Herbi. Most of the answers he had given me were “I think this of this person but not sure” type answers. But when pressed about Herbi, his answer of “Herbi’s the strawberry floating Alpha.” was presented with such belief and conviction, yet was so massively wrong.
I thought it was funny so I print screened it and stuck it in my signature. So whilst I was no longer posting in the game thread I was still posting around the forum, and it created some unintentional hysteria. People started noticing it and those that at that point may have been on the fence about it were now becoming convinced, one by one, until 24 hours later, the night after I died, the seer network finally managed to get Herbi lynched. Cora had the honour of lynching the guy that was pretty much universally accepted as being the Alpha Wolf. Herbi by this time had accepted his fate and had stopped denying this assertion as it was clear there was no escape for him. And so, the time came. When it was revealed that, he was in fact NOT the Alpha Wolf, but just a simple VILLAGER, there were pages and pages of responses, some shocked, some confused, some angry, some crying. People just had no idea what had happened.