GRcade Mafia | Game 1 Thread | The Illicit Gang of Nobodies

[Kezzer]

what was PPM's role?

[Hexx]

Presumably - he wouldn't ask people to send night PMs without knowing the results of a lynch (or if it's a no lynch :p but while some are unhappy I'm here no ones wants to help in case their wrong )

[Nun]

VOTE: Hexx is guilty

Would have happily voted to kill Drummy today if only Hexx had bothered to just role claim rather than being stubborn.

[Hexx]

Yeah. I'm the stubborn one.

Remind me what I've done beside refuse to go along with terrible plan that I said wouldn't work and then didn't work.

[PaperMacheMario]

what was PPM's role?

Is it worth me revealing it right now?

Kind of agree with Nun on Hexx. He seems innocent to me, but could have saved a whole lot of confusion and in turn helped get us the right person if he had have disclosed his role.

[Hexx]

And you then ignored the only piece of strawberry floating concrete helpful you lucked info cus a seer had possibly been lucky

[Hexx]

what was PPM's role?

Is it worth me revealing it right now?

Kind of agree with Nun on Hexx. He seems innocent to me, but could have saved a whole lot of confusion and in turn helped get us the right person if he had have disclosed his role.

I don't know how many times I can say revealing my role with wants known/claimed in the board wouldn't clear up confusion, it would only add to it.

Role disclosure only adds to confusion if a small amount do it.

You want to know something? Pretend I've claimed the survivor (obviously not if you're the survivor :p) - there. Look at all the helpful info the town got. Wow. Doesn't that make it much clearer wether I'm guilty/innocent

[Kezzer]

Pfft like you believed SS64 - he effectively said 'one of us two is a Mafia'

I even basically admitted I have no helpful info to give anyway - so you didn't believe him, why would you believe me? (work it out - you might think it's plausible if you're reached the option(s) organically)

Even no one role claiming the same wouldn't save as people aren't always here - unianimous action remember?

I'm not trying to convince you, it's the swingers - and I think the easiest way to that is to repeat the pros/cons before rather than open up a whole new line of arguement 'Hexx says he's X. There's no evidence so we believe him?''

SD64 has claimed COP and said that Drummy and Moggy were suspicious - bare in mind that it just so happens that Moggy is a dead Mafia... go figure. This and the fact that he and you were actively trying to stop the plan that would help the town makes you both suspicious.


As for Pros and Cons:

Qikz has carried over other nights - if you want to vote do it (although I would say that)

'Prove my innocence'? Why don't you prove guilt?

Let's look at pros and cons shall we?

Pro

Didn't vote Rhubard - I didn't vote guilty/innocent... so it doesn't prove anything as he was the first lynchee - someone had to go up it was luck of the draw ( it could have been you if you hadn't posted)

Focused SK (who the Mafia would want alive) - mafia wouldn't want the SK alive as he killed a mafia on the first night...

Can't be Mafioso ... can still be god-father.

Con

Didn't go ahead with Kezzer's plan and explain in logical steps why it's a bad idea since it depended far too much on Town acting unanimously and unison. (Which by the way, it didn't)

- Actively disrupted the thread and cast doubt on a plan that would work if the town was honest with each other. Because you refused to be honest, others started to follow suit.

Edit: sorry my responses are in red

[Kezzer]

what was PPM's role?

Is it worth me revealing it right now?

Kind of agree with Nun on Hexx. He seems innocent to me, but could have saved a whole lot of confusion and in turn helped get us the right person if he had have disclosed his role.

absolutely it helps

[Hexx]

Guys, sorry for being late but I was late home from work/on a train so I couldn't check everything.

Hexx is up on the dock as per the deadline you can either

VOTE: GUILTY

or

VOTE: INNOCENT

Boom!

VOTE: INNOCENT

Nothing in the rules said I can't vote. I checked.

Only one they did it right too. I win suckers! Unkillable!

(This is an obvious joke - says how to vote one way here other in OP. Both should count. Just like the idea of Getting myself off (snicker) as only voter)

[Hexx]

Pfft like you believed SS64 - he effectively said 'one of us two is a Mafia'

I even basically admitted I have no helpful info to give anyway - so you didn't believe him, why would you believe me? (work it out - you might think it's plausible if you're reached the option(s) organically)

Even no one role claiming the same wouldn't save as people aren't always here - unianimous action remember?

I'm not trying to convince you, it's the swingers - and I think the easiest way to that is to repeat the pros/cons before rather than open up a whole new line of arguement 'Hexx says he's X. There's no evidence so we believe him?''

SD64 has claimed COP and said that Drummy and Moggy were suspicious - bare in mind that it just so happens that Moggy is a dead Mafia... go figure. This and the fact that he and you were actively trying to stop the plan that would help the town makes you both suspicious.


As for Pros and Cons:

Qikz has carried over other nights - if you want to vote do it (although I would say that)

'Prove my innocence'? Why don't you prove guilt?

Let's look at pros and cons shall we?

Pro

Didn't vote Rhubard - I didn't vote guilty/innocent... so it doesn't prove anything as he was the first lynchee - someone had to go up it was luck of the draw ( it could have been you if you hadn't posted)

Focused SK (who the Mafia would want alive) - mafia wouldn't want the SK alive as he killed a mafia on the first night...

Can't be Mafioso ... can still be god-father.

Con

Didn't go ahead with Kezzer's plan and explain in logical steps why it's a bad idea since it depended far too much on Town acting unanimously and unison. (Which by the way, it didn't)

- Actively disrupted the thread and cast doubt on a plan that would work if the town was honest with each other. Because you refused to be honest, others started to follow suit.

Edit: sorry my responses are in red

Dude. 'would work' you plan had utterly failed in execution. It di You've given info to the Mafia and made have th

***Sorry finger slip. So editing rather than deleting. Dude your plan hasn't worked. You got 3/8, and gave away more info than you learned. The fact you are still on about this great plan ;lol; being disrupted illustrates yet again you being petty than an actual arguement.

And they'll lynch you tomorrow when no one gets shot tonight

[Kezzer]

how can the mafia use the info in any meaningful way? who are they going to kill?

[PaperMacheMario]

what was PPM's role?

Is it worth me revealing it right now?

Kind of agree with Nun on Hexx. He seems innocent to me, but could have saved a whole lot of confusion and in turn helped get us the right person if he had have disclosed his role.

I don't know how many times I can say revealing my role with wants known/claimed in the board wouldn't clear up confusion, it would only add to it.

Role disclosure only adds to confusion if a small amount do it.

You want to know something? Pretend I've claimed the survivor (obviously not if you're the survivor :p) - there. Look at all the helpful info the town got. Wow. Doesn't that make it much clearer wether I'm guilty/innocent

I don't think it would have added to the confusion. For the town it would have given us more chance of lynching someone else, and so in your opinion more chance of winning. For you personally it would probably have saved your life. Even if it was adding to the confusion, would it not have been better to just reveal it?

what was PPM's role?

Is it worth me revealing it right now?

Kind of agree with Nun on Hexx. He seems innocent to me, but could have saved a whole lot of confusion and in turn helped get us the right person if he had have disclosed his role.

absolutely it helps

I actually am the Survivor.

[Kezzer]

Right now who is Laga?

[Hexx]

how can the mafia use the info in any meaningful way? who are they going to kill?

They know more roles than you can defend.

You've focused on me (and SD64) and let others stay in the shadows umexamknds because you had to be right, despite the rationale presented, rather than smart

[Kezzer]

And they'll lynch you tomorrow when no one gets shot tonight

And that's the beauty of the Vigilanty role in this game... it is the only self proving role.

[Hexx]

And they'll lynch you tomorrow when no one gets shot tonight

And that's the beauty of the Vigilanty role in this game... it is the only self proving role.

No. That's the Vetren.

Edit - misread you sorry

Gah edit rule

[Hexx]

Out of interest - if it's after 8 (for a bit) do you want to me to reveal what you lot have just done so you can...reflect on it.
Or wait for Qikz to come back from the cinema?

[Kezzer]

Incorrect. Only a Mafia would claim to be the Vigilante while the actual Vigilante was still in play.

A towns person would know what their actual role was and so presumably would not reveal as Vigilante because they run the risk of getting shot by the actual Vigilante...

[Kezzer]

I have just checked my watch... technically Hexx is dead

we can say he is still hanging and the fall didn't break his neck so he is slowly suffocating.