GRcade

Joer wrote:You can do a Hugo Recommends thread to go alongside this one where you tell us how wrong we are and how the list should look if you want.

Good idea.

But I was actually commenting on contents wise its not all that bad really.

I still think it'd be a good idea to have links to the voting threads in the OP.

I've found the threads

Nintendo 64, Xbox, PlayStation and Gamecube

Restarted Mario Sunshine last night, I used to think this game was hard as strawberry float now I'm breezing through it I already have 60 shines and I haven't even done the hotel level yet. It's really good, I think I might like it more than Galaxy.

Dig Dug wrote:Restarted Mario Sunshine last night, I used to think this game was hard as strawberry float now I'm breezing through it I already have 60 shines and I haven't even done the hotel level yet. It's really good, I think I might like it more than Galaxy.

I hope they do an HD rerelease on the Wii U. I think it might be time for a play through again soon.

Thanks to some requests in the Xbox thread i've posted those results up now too. The post is obviously not finished as I don't have the time at the moment so will get it done when I do unless someone wants to volunteer. Will add in the voting threads to the OP too as requested by Dan earlier on in the thread.

Joer.

EDIT: Xbox top 5 are all amazing games.

Dan. wrote:Joer. :wub:

EDIT: Xbox top 5 are all amazing games.

Except for Halo 2. Not sure how anyone could call that game amazing.

Granted the online MP was ahead of its time, but the SP was distinctly...well bad.

HSH28 wrote:

Dan. wrote:Joer.

EDIT: Xbox top 5 are all amazing games.

Except for Halo 2. Not sure how anyone could call that game amazing.

Granted the online MP was ahead of its time, but the SP was distinctly...well bad.

People vote it for Halo 2 MP, instead of the single player campaign, no?

Wedgie wrote:People vote it for Halo 2 MP, instead of the single player campaign, no?

That isn't a game though. Halo 2 is the whole package as such it should be treated like that as far as I'm concerned.

Wedgie wrote:

HSH28 wrote:

Dan. wrote:Joer.

EDIT: Xbox top 5 are all amazing games.

Except for Halo 2. Not sure how anyone could call that game amazing.

Granted the online MP was ahead of its time, but the SP was distinctly...well bad.

People vote it for Halo 2 MP, instead of the single player campaign, no?

I would think so. I can also only assume that the reason Halo came out above the sequel was because of the vastly superior SP campaign.

They are both great games and were both bound to be in there. The main thing is that 1 > 2. No reason to fault the list otherwise.

Well, the voters seem to disagree with you.

GOD LOVES DEMOCRACY!

Wedgie wrote:Well, the voters seem to disagree with you.

GOD LOVES DEMOCRACY!

I prefer Meritocracy.

Gonna go ahead and get this going again thanks to the popular demand of the thing. Going to do two at the same time. Was thinking of Dreamcast and one other, first suggestion wins.

I've only just seen this topic... GTA2 made the PlayStation list but no GTA in sight GRcade never fails to get things wrong.

[iup=3587648]Joer[/iup] wrote:Gonna go ahead and get this going again thanks to the popular demand of the thing. Going to do two at the same time. Was thinking of Dreamcast and one other, first suggestion wins.

GBA if it's not been done.

GBA it is. Dreamcast thread is up here - t:grecommends-sega-dreamcast?f=2

GBA will be up in five minutes! EDIT: here it is - t:grecommends-game-boy-advance?f=2

When you do the DS it'd be great if people could indicate which games can be played with just the stylus.

Thanks to emulation I can still actually play quite a few DS games, unlike most other consoles/Handhelds. I can't wait until someone emulates the 3DS.

Sure, will certainly look at adding that in for you. Hopefully there's a site somewhere which has it all listed already which will make things a bit easier when double checking.

Just an asterisk next to a games name would be enough.

Thanks.

I'd normally ask on the disabled gamers forum I post on but it's almost a ghost town these days, besides that hardly anyone on there has a DS.

GBA results are all up and in the first post. Gonna take me a while to do the Dreamcast one I think because I lost motivation to do it after getting half way through the GBA list and seeing how long it took me.