GRcade

The results are in and in a GRecommends first, every single person voted for the top game in their top 10.

Quick results


1st
Mario Kart 8
Nintendo EAD, Nintendo
2014


2nd
Super Mario 3D World
Nintendo EAD Tokyo, Nintendo
2013


3rd
Super Mario Maker
Nintendo EAD, Nintendo
2015


4th
Splatoon
Nintendo EAD, Nintendo
2015


5th
The Legend of Zelda: The Breath of the Wild
Nintendo EPD, Nintendo
2016


6th=
Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker
Nintendo EAD Tokyo, Nintendo
2014


6th=
Pikmin 3
Nintendo EAD, Nintendo
2013


8th
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Retro Studios/Monster Games, Nintendo
2014


9th=
Bayonetta 2
PlatinumGames, Nintendo
2014


9th=
Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
Bandai Namco Games/Sora, Nintendo
2014


9th=
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD
Nintendo EAD, Nintendo
2013


Bubbling under: New Super Mario Bros. U (Nintendo EAD, 2012), Xenoblade Chronicles X (Monolith Soft/Nintendo SPD, 2015)

Total games nominated: 37, Total voters: 19, Total votes: 175

Thanks for voting!

Decent list of games but Donkey Kong is way too far down it.

I think personally I'd put Mario Maker above 3D World. Even though 3D World is entirely new and gooseberry fool, Mario Maker got so much play time out of me compared to SM3DW.

chalkitdown wrote:Decent list of games but Donkey Kong is way too far down it. :|

Way too far up the list. Swap it for The Wonderful 101 for a far better top 10.

Seeing Zelda at 5 is just weird without knowing the context of many people (like me) not voting for it as we have it on Switch

I can't really argue with that list to be honest, even if for me Mario Maker should have topped it personally.

OrangeRakoon wrote:Seeing Zelda at 5 is just weird without knowing the context of many people (like me) not voting for it as we have it on Switch

I voted for it and I've only got it on Switch. Technically the U version is a bit weaker but it's otherwise identical.

I only vote on games that I played on the system itself.like in the ps3 one there were multiplatform games I loved but didn't play them on PS3, so they didn't get my vote. Probably just being fussy though.

If I didn't limit my votes I'd just be repeatedly voting for Ocarina of Time on every Nintendo home console post SNES

And my PS3 vote would be full of PS2 games.

Pedz wrote:I only vote on games that I played on the system itself...

Same here, man. I also only vote for games that I've played a fair amount of, hence my list was pretty short and didn't have Breath on it (even though I know it's good enough to be right near the top of the chart).

Wish I'd played Tokyo Mirage Sessions, Star Fox Zero and Paper Mario Colour Splash before I voted. Really like all three games.

Smash Bros a bit low down for my tastes, but other than that a pretty solid list!