[Vigilantes chat] TRIBE VS TRIBE

[OrangeRKN]

ORKN's vote was for "Red Tribe" and it's been counted in the Vote Quote as for "Red Tribe". I think that's the correct outcome.

Correct!

The confusion was funny though

[site23]

X

EDIT: Just testing whether Preezy's problem was affecting all the threads or just him. Guess it's just him!

[OrangeRKN]

We should start tracking votes for sure, but more importantly first of all we should throw together a simple spreadsheet/matrix of all other players against the 3 other tribes so we can easily keep track of what has been confirmed and ruled out (for now, knowing superchris isn't tribe yer eyes so we can block out that cell in red or something).

Actually it might be worth doing the same including all of us and all 4 tribes so we can track the "public" perspective and stay aware of what the other tribes know about us.

[OrangeRKN]

I also can't figure much reason to post in the public game thread, especially not anything useful, except to get the activity bonus and to try and earn some points by voting. Better to keep any theorycrafting guarded.

On how wolves might work, I suspect it will either become evident through some extra unexpected kills being made, or (given there is no points earning potential for tribes from it) they might get points for being part of a successful lynch at the weekend.

[sawyerpip]

I'm currently making a spreadsheet tracking activity and votes so will add in this matrix to track knowledge.

Is everyone happy to PM me their email address so I can grant access? Alternatively I can make it public and post the link here, I'm just anxious of somehow the link getting out and outing ourselves to everyone

EDIT: Just to note that only Curls did not post day 1 so there is one tribe who is behind on the accumulation of powers.

[OrangeRKN]

sawyerpip doing God's work

I'd rather it was public tbh... there's probably a lone wolf here but if they had reason to leak info (which would seem harsh!) they could just as easily screenshot/copy any spreadsheet as share a public link.

[sawyerpip]

Spreadsheet link here - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing

Should be fairly self-explanatory but any questions/suggestions let me know.

[sawyerpip]

What do we make of the SuperChris theories? It does seem perhaps unlikely that he would bring Pro-Village into the deadlock mix right at the deadline if he was part of that tribe. But then again, tribes have 8 members so it would be quite easy to have agreed for another member to add or switch a vote without causing too much controversy, Cuttooth switched his vote to break the deadlock and no-one is really scrutinising it.

If Chris goes back up we have a 50/50 of getting their tribe right and so potentially gaining points if it's the majority, although would need to be wary of what could be given away in the voting pattern, TYEM would be working from the least amount of knowledge in the vote and so at a disadvantage.

[OrangeRKN]

.

If we are all active for 3 consecutive days, do we earn both a SAVE and a KILL or does redeeming 2 days for a SAVE mean the consecutive day count resets?

Say we were active for 4 consecutive days (and then broke the streak), would we have 2 SAVES and a KILL in the bank ready to use, or would we have the choice between 2 SAVES or 1 KILL?

[OrangeRKN]

Cuttooth switched his vote to break the deadlock and no-one is really scrutinising it.

Do you think it's unlikely Cuttooth is in TYEM given that's how he broke the deadlock? If he was, he'd have been deliberately throwing any chance of points. There are reasons he might have done that but they seem less likely imo.

The spreadsheets are great btw!

[sawyerpip]

Cuttooth switched his vote to break the deadlock and no-one is really scrutinising it.

Do you think it's unlikely Cuttooth is in TYEM given that's how he broke the deadlock? If he was, he'd have been deliberately throwing any chance of points. There are reasons he might have done that but they seem less likely imo.

The spreadsheets are great btw!

Yeah, that's a good point, I agree it is probably less likely that he is in TYEM and voted knowing that Chris wasn't a member, considering that he initially made his vote to PV fairly close to the deadline while the votes were already quite close, so would seem odd to suddenly vote for your own tribe and throw an opportunity at points when you could have done that before the deadline to ensure a TYEM majority if that was your strategy. Perhaps Chris's vote for PV convinced him that PV was wrong, which would mean he's also less likely to be PV himself, leaving him as a potential Red Triber.

[Herdanos]

.

If we are all active for 3 consecutive days, do we earn both a SAVE and a KILL or does redeeming 2 days for a SAVE mean the consecutive day count resets?

Say we were active for 4 consecutive days (and then broke the streak), would we have 2 SAVES and a KILL in the bank ready to use, or would we have the choice between 2 SAVES or 1 KILL?

Redeeming for a save resets the count

In your example scenario you'd have to choose between redeeming your days for 2 saves or 1 kill

[sawyerpip]

Is anyone in the GRcade whatsapp group and if so did they see Mommy's deleted messages? Wondering if Clarkman is onto something or just a red herring.

I'd have thought Chris was an easy choice to nominate again so I expect a couple of the voters looking elsewhere today to be a part of his tribe.

[Roonmastor]

Not in the group. Wondering if they are using it as a way to evaluate who is in a tribe with a GRcade WhatsApp member

[OrangeRKN]

I'm not sure which tactic to use here:

1) Vote Mommy for TYEM. Slightly better odds if you consider we've already eliminated one person from being in the tribe, so the points payoff is marginally better.

2) Vote Mommy (and every suspect) for Red Tribe. If I stick to the same tribe every time that's a 1/3 chance of some points while trying to minimise info I'm giving the thread on my own tribe. Might be too obvious a tactic though to draw attention and people could reasonably infer I'm not in Red Tribe and have a 50/50 read on me.

3) Alternate votes evenly between all 4 tribes. 1/4 days have a zero chance of scoring points but it gives nothing away about my allegiance.

4) Don't vote and give nothing away.

I think on typing it out and reflecting I'm leaning (3), which means I should go for one of PV, TYEM or V today. TYEM has the better odds on an otherwise free choice so I might go with that!

[Qikz]

Is anyone in the GRcade whatsapp group and if so did they see Mommy's deleted messages? Wondering if Clarkman is onto something or just a red herring.

I'd have thought Chris was an easy choice to nominate again so I expect a couple of the voters looking elsewhere today to be a part of his tribe.

I'm in the group but I didn't see the messages.

[sawyerpip]

Is anyone in the GRcade whatsapp group and if so did they see Mommy's deleted messages? Wondering if Clarkman is onto something or just a red herring.

I'd have thought Chris was an easy choice to nominate again so I expect a couple of the voters looking elsewhere today to be a part of his tribe.

I'm in the group but I didn't see the messages.

Was there any discussion of or reaction to the messages after the deletion? Quite hilarious if Mommy genuinely messaged the group chat giving away his tribe, but does seem like it could all be contrived to some end.

[Qikz]

Is anyone in the GRcade whatsapp group and if so did they see Mommy's deleted messages? Wondering if Clarkman is onto something or just a red herring.

I'd have thought Chris was an easy choice to nominate again so I expect a couple of the voters looking elsewhere today to be a part of his tribe.

I'm in the group but I didn't see the messages.

Was there any discussion of or reaction to the messages after the deletion? Quite hilarious if Mommy genuinely messaged the group chat giving away his tribe, but does seem like it could all be contrived to some end.

Just someone else deleting their message telling him likely to delete his message.

[sawyerpip]

.

.

.

Just a gentle reminder that the four of us need to post in the game thread by midnight to keep our tribe on track for gaining powers.

[site23]

Are we deliberately not having anyone vote with Clarkman on this? I'm kind of tempted to have one of us do it (and I'm happy to do it!) but I wanted to ask first...!