Page 37 of 39
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:13 pm
by G-Rat
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:14 pm
by Captain Kinopio
Oblomov Boblomov - Deceased Mafia - Jumped out a window
Mini E - Deceased Mafia - Run Over
The Master - Deceased Mafia - Death by Firing Mob
smurphy - Deceased Detective - Shotgun blast to the chest
AJ Styles - Deceased Townsfolk - Thrown into the River Cade
aaronayl1 - Deceased Townsfolk- Shot in the head
Zenigame - Survived Townsfolk
Cuttooth - Survived Townsfolk
Irene Demova - Survived Townsfolk
Drumstick - Survived Townsfolk
HM - Survived Townsfolk
PCCD - Survived Nurse
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:14 pm
by The People's ElboReformat
Cuttooth wrote:You guys tried to question my judgement.
Put it up there winners!
o/
\o
I was seriously starting to suspect you as being Mafia. And if Mini E had proven to be townsfolk and we had both survived the night I was going to make a post along the lines of "I think Cutty is mafia and hasn't killed me off because I'm a good decoy" or something. Hoping you wouldn't make the same kind of post before me.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:15 pm
by A J Styles
If only Mini E died yesterday.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:18 pm
by The People's ElboReformat
A J Styles wrote::cry:
If only Mini E died yesterday.
Really sorry AJ. You did yourself no favours with some of your posts but I admit to making the mistake of pursuing you for them.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:18 pm
by Drumstick
\o/
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:18 pm
by The People's ElboReformat
Oh and many thanks for running the game Herbi. Was good fun. Well done.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:20 pm
by Captain Kinopio
Good game chaps.
After 5 days of nothing I was starting to panic a bit
thank christ for smurphy, who did effectively win you the game, despite the best efforts of PCCD
shame he couldn't see the game out but PCCD didn't protect him leaving him open for Mini E to kill
I was generally very impressed with the Townsfolk investigation. Looked for a moment like Mini E was going to get a few days of peace but a couple of you really spun it round on him on Sunday, he deflected well but you could tell he wasn't going to last the distance from that point on.
Mini E you played your role well, your big flaw (missed opportunity perhaps) was not voting with Nood the night smurphy revealed all. PCCD backed out of protecting him so it would have bagged you guys a kill and could perhaps have kept the game going a bit longer.
Mafia in general suffered from this being the first game like this. Only once did two of them manage to get the same name, I think they were a little over cautious really, apart from the KILL ZENIGAME post (which I thought had a decent chance of working) I couldn't really see any attempts at communication between the lot of you.
I feel bad for aaron too, PCCD has some questions to answer
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:22 pm
by Mini E
Thanks Herbi - good man
Sorry for setting you up yesterday AJ
Nothing personal
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:24 pm
by Cuttooth
Zenigame wrote:Oh and many thanks for running the game Herbi. Was good fun. Well done.
I concur. Good post count, Herbs.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:24 pm
by G-Rat
When's the next one Herbi?
I'm expressing my interest right now.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:28 pm
by A J Styles
Mini E wrote:Thanks Herbi - good man
Sorry for setting you up yesterday AJ
Nothing personal
It's ok, played your role perfect though!
And Zenigame it's fine i shouldn't be as stupid to look like Mafia.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:33 pm
by Mini E
G-Ratasaurus Rex wrote:When's the next one Herbi?
I'm expressing my interest right now.
This
I want in again
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:37 pm
by A J Styles
Mini E wrote:G-Ratasaurus Rex wrote:When's the next one Herbi?
I'm expressing my interest right now.
This
I want in again
This, i think you should double the amount of Mafia, Townsfolk and have two nurses though.
Cheers for running the game Herbi was pretty fun!
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:40 pm
by Drumstick
Zenigame wrote:Oh and many thanks for running the game Herbi. Was good fun. Well done.
This.
I did enjoy it even though it was pretty dull at the start. The serial whingers did start to annoy me and I contemplated making some bold move (I'd not decided what) but the game then started to move once Smurphy came out of hiding.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:51 pm
by Irene Demova
Cheers to Herbi and Smurphy you both made the game (Herbi literary)
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:52 pm
by smurphy
Yeah, I thought it was excellent. The low number of players really helps it I think. Everyone is a suspect, and individual posts actually mean something. When I was a seer years ago in AYAW it was like trying to find a needle in a haystack, and even if I got a wolf it wouldn't make much of a dent in the overall pack. They're different games though, really.
I'd never actually seered Aaron at all.
If he was the last wolf I would've left you all believing he was Townsfolk. I just trusted he was safe so much it felt like a wasted opportunity. The night I said I'd done him I really did Cutty.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:55 pm
by The People's ElboReformat
smurphy wrote:I'd never actually seered Aaron at all.
If he was the last wolf I would've left you all believing he was Townsfolk. I just trusted he was safe so much it felt like a wasted opportunity. The night I said I'd done him I really did Cutty.
I don't know if I'd been happy if you had mentioned this or not.
Would have taken away the suspicions I had of Cutty, but he was also my escape goat (sic) if fingers started pointing to me.
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 8:56 pm
by Captain Kinopio
A J Styles wrote:Mini E wrote:G-Ratasaurus Rex wrote:When's the next one Herbi?
I'm expressing my interest right now.
This
I want in again
This, i think you should double the amount of Mafia, Townsfolk and have two nurses though.
Cheers for running the game Herbi was pretty fun!
I can't imagine ever doing one with more than 20 players, it's too time consuming.
Plus some rule flaws need to be ironed out.
It's fun to do though, as long as you're not trying to make up story when nothing is happening
Re: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2010 9:33 pm
by Cuttooth
smurphy wrote:I'd never actually seered Aaron at all.
If he was the last wolf I would've left you all believing he was Townsfolk. I just trusted he was safe so much it felt like a wasted opportunity. The night I said I'd done him I really did Cutty.
Well that was risky.