FatDaz wrote:You have raised some valid points, HSH28 didn't address any of why he thought I was wrong.
FatDaz wrote:Without wanting to feed the troll but... go on which bits are plain wrong? And which do YOU consider to be only minor?
I thought it had pretty much been covered. But clearly the following points are wrong
FatDaz wrote:+ Actual sets and props
+ Only prequel with actual space battle
+ Less terrible dialogue (not great but no "sand" lines or "in my opinion the Jedi are evil")
FatDaz wrote:+ nice multiple action / location ending similar to ROTJ
I disagree with that and even if you liked the ending the fact you think it might be similar to ROTJ is a very minor point which I'm not even sure is a plus.
FatDaz wrote:+ Pod race was great
And that you can probably tell I don't think was great. Sure its much better than the surrounding parts of the film, but taken on its own its not as good a set piece as people seem to give it credit for.
Actually thinking about it these two points I have issues with too...
FatDaz wrote:+ great soundtrack duel of the fates is superb
+ best light sabre battle the 2 v 1 maul fight
All the music is great, so pointing out that the music in this film is great is irrelevant. And that light sabre fight...well although it was good at the time, its very easy to pick it apart.