Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Warning: Spoilers in thread

Personally I'd say this is comfortably the worst of the new films. Rewatched just the other day , does absolutely nothing for me. The CGI is some of the worst in movie history.

Last edited by Tomous on Mon Dec 25, 2017 9:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.

I think the final third is the strongest part and it's done pretty well but the film is largely too forgettable which is probably because the main characters are just do dull and boring.

It certainly has a lot less problems and issues than TLJ though.

Tomous wrote:I think the final third is the strongest party and it's done pretty well but the film is largely too forgettable which is probably because the main characters are just do dull and boring.

It certainly has a lot less problems and issues than TLJ though.

Ferdinand has less holes than TLJ. Doesn't make it a better film though.

That end scene :datass:

DML wrote:
Tomous wrote:I think the final third is the strongest party and it's done pretty well but the film is largely too forgettable which is probably because the main characters are just do dull and boring.

It certainly has a lot less problems and issues than TLJ though.

Ferdinand has less holes than TLJ. Doesn't make it a better film though.

Ferdinand?

My point is TLJ had far more issues and things that annoyed me than Rogue One so I prefer that even if Rogue One is abit dull for a lot of the film. I am probably harsher on TLJ as it is part of the new trilogy rather than a spin off though.

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Warning: Spoilers in thread

Who is online

Affiliates

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story **Warning: Spoilers in thread**

Who is online

Affiliates

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Warning: Spoilers in thread