Just got into this, binged on the first 6 episodes at work and on my commute. At present it definitely seems a very dodgy conviction, but I have to temper that against a feeling that we aren't getting the full story either.
[iup=3610651]Kevin McCallister[/iup] wrote:That car park is nowhere near as secluded as it has been made out to be. Would be pretty risky to strangle someone and move their body into the boot there.
I actually found it to be more secluded that I imagined! Having said that, it would have been risky as you say, although not against the realms of possibility. I used to work on a car park (trolley boy) and to be honest I didn't really pay much interest to my surroundings. I went to ASDA tonight and I'm pretty much on autopilot from the car to the store. It isn't impossible to move a body unseen, but highly unlikely. That's my issue so far, the prosecution case isn't impossible, but I find it highly unlikely.
The guy who found the body seems an interesting loose end, given his record and his explanation on finding the body, he definitely seems worth investigating (did he have an alibi?). But then the problem with that is that it doesn't match at all with Jay's involvement.
EDIT: I also wonder how much the jury were shown. For example, you see above that from the description in the podcast and on the maps that myself and Kevin had wildly different impressions of the "crime scene". I'd hope the jury were actually taken there, it's so easy to get the wrong impression of the scene from just descriptions.
Also, how is it alledged Adnan got to the Best Buy? Wasn't it proven that he didn't go with the victim, and Jay had his car?