Saboteur: Accounts Revealed!

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **DML** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 12:41 am

Very well done DR. I personally wouldn't have had anonymous accounts as an idea. Although I had my doubts on Days One and Two (I found it all a bit confusing and overwhelming) the characters in the game started to grow and make it thoroughly deep and interesting. In that regard the experiment was very much a success.

However, the same old tactics came out again - the seer/Mayor rotation, and the next time I run this game, that will be dying for GOOD. GR needs to learn to play the game without its safety net, and oh it will.

Excellent game DR, been great food for thought, and I think you've run it smashingly.

Corazon de Leon

The seer/mayor thing didn't happen though. Zeni was only mayor right at the end. :shifty:

Kanbei wrote:Yup great job! Thinking about it more, anonymous accounts were definitely a good thing. It's just that people weren't as active as they should have been (including myself in this).

Zenigame has got to go down in AYA? history as the best seer. He was awesome for us when BLADEFORCE won a few games ago.

The Alchemist Penguin wrote:
Reindeer Games wrote:
The Detective, Sonata! Otherwise known as Zenigame! Backed up by ever-present Nurse, Whirlpool- The Alchemist Penguin.

Zenigame and The Irish Penguin. The ultimate team.

I would never have pegged you as Sonata. I doubt I would have trusted you if I had known it was you! The anonymous account system works!

Destiny put us together and it proved we are a perfect partnership. :wub:

Nood be raging.

Santa Paws wrote:Very well done DR. I personally wouldn't have had anonymous accounts as an idea. Although I had my doubts on Days One and Two (I found it all a bit confusing and overwhelming) the characters in the game started to grow and make it thoroughly deep and interesting. In that regard the experiment was very much a success.

However, the same old tactics came out again - the seer/Mayor rotation, and the next time I run this game, that will be dying for GOOD. GR needs to learn to play the game without its safety net, and oh it will.

Ain't no seer/Mayor rotation this time. Wasn't wanting to go down that route either because i know it takes the fun out of it for others. Think I asked TAP if he thought we should go down that route but nothing really came from it lukily. Also I was paranoid that if we did do that there could be a twist one day where there'd be no mayor or something.

Guys Verduran is obviously CommShep.

And strawberry float y'all for killing me. I never got to use my bullet.

As a spectator, I do have to say that Reverse (Jenko) was easily one of the worst Citizens I've ever seen. If I was playing I'd probably have been camaigning to get rid of him after the antics of day 2. :fp:

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Turboman** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 2:25 am

The Holly and Delusi wrote:As a spectator, I do have to say that Reverse (Jenko) was easily one of the worst Citizens I've ever seen. If I was playing I'd probably have been camaigning to get rid of him after the antics of day 2.

Well said.

Awesome stuff, very interesting to see who certain people were. Aside from Deadpool I correctly identified Parksey as Zenith, but that's about it. It was a bit annoying to identify The Saboteur and then not have the glory to personally take him down myself, but I shouldn't complain. At that point I was rather hopeful of surviving a game but I guess the unwanted attention I heaped on Zellery (Vicious) sealed my fate. Props to DP for taking my theory/evidence forward though and I'm amazed he had any trust in me whatsoever considering the things I've done to him in past during these games. Other than myself, Parksey and DP, I thought Satriales (Sentry), Dan (Sunweb), Elbo (Sonata) and Tiarny (Whirlpool) all played a very good game.

Huge thanks to DR for running it.

Zells & Holly wrote:Have the Wolves ever won these games?

I haven't been in many but the two I have been have both been Citizen victories.

Yeah, AYAW II & V both saw Werewolf victories, both landslides too.

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Ironhide** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 2:24 pm

Oh Teh Snows wrote:Guys Verduran is obviously CommShep.

And strawberry float y'all for killing me. I never got to use my bullet.

I was a bit annoyed at being killed on the same night.

Although I suspect the Sab realised I was a vigilante when I made a slightly incriminating post which I subsequently deleted.

I came close to shooting Reverse though.

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Pedz** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 3:03 pm

So, who's doing Are You A Cylon? In the future? Someone better!

Really enjoyed this game. Wss more involved than other games I've been in. By involved I don't mean posted more. As I probably posted more in my last game played which was the one in my sig.

I've only just caught up on the thread :lol:

Haven't been online since I made my last post and the one that immediately follows it is:

Sonata wrote:No need to keep this hidden anymore. I'm the Detective that I said I was in contact with. The guy that found Researcher and told Whirlpool of.

I guessed this 8-)

I PM'd Sonata to tell him to get Whirlpool to protect him in case the remaining accomplice might also guess :lol:

I was also certain I was going to be lynched the night Natwest died - so much so I even composed an elaborate death post which I'll now never get to use, so may as well post:

Primal wrote:If we had a kill on the night vicious was lynched, it would have been you[Sentry] and sunweb

I feel that I owe Satriales an apology, for throwing suspicion on him all game - you played a great game dude. :wub:

Also a big sorry to Clarkman for scrutinizing his every post and also throwing suspicion on him too.

Although I survived until the very end, I wasn't actually very good this time around :lol:

I never suspected the right people at all. Compared to the last AYAV? in which I thought I played OK, this time I was just really, really lucky.

Well played though other citizens :wub:

And thanks DR for running the game :wub:

(initially I kept getting confused when I saw people targeting 'DR' for questions as DR are my initials :fp:

)

Theo wrote:Other than myself, Parksey and DP, I thought Satriales (Sentry), Dan (Sunweb), Elbo (Sonata) and Tiarny (Whirlpool) all played a very good game.

So what happens to our alt accounts now?

Oh, and this thread needs to be archived IMO. :mrgreen:

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Sputnik** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 5:07 pm

Robot Santa wrote:
Oh Teh Snows wrote:Guys Verduran is obviously CommShep.

And strawberry float y'all for killing me. I never got to use my bullet.

I was a bit annoyed at being killed on the same night.

Although I suspect the Sab realised I was a vigilante when I made a slightly incriminating post which I subsequently deleted.

I didn't think you were a vigilante, but you made a post that said something like you originally had 3 strong suspicions, two of which had been refuted, and so just in case I was the third one I told Vicious to kill you soon.

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Herdanos** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 5:08 pm

Aaaand back to using my normal account.

PostRe: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Zellery** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 5:24 pm

Has The Alpha/Dracula ever had one time use powers before that have a chance to completely fail? :fp:

I found that slightly dampened the game for me. What's the point in having a special role who has two powers to use once but with the chance of them not even working, thus diluting your special role?

Sunweb wrote:I feel that I owe Satriales an apology, for throwing suspicion on him all game - you played a great game dude.

It's all right, I started it when I ran for mayor and tried to put you up for the lynch. :oops:

I just wanted to put out two names that I wasn't sure about as everyone else had focused on Koilos. But the Koilos hate was too strong and in hindsight it was better to get rid of him than either of my two candidates.

Good game. :mrgreen:

PostRe: Re: Saboteur: Accounts Revealed! by **Pedz** » Sun Dec 18, 2011 5:38 pm

Zells & Holly wrote:Has The Alpha/Dracula ever had one time use powers before that have a chance to completely fail?

I found that slightly dampened the game for me. What's the point in having a special role who has two powers to use once but with the chance of them not even working, thus diluting your special role?

I don't think they have had any. I think the whole undetecable evil player is their main 'power'.

Yeah, the 'powers' thing was an experiment. I felt the chance for failure needed to be there to balance out the power, as it's an extremely powerful one.

What was the punishment that we were going to receive after Reverse kept posting from the grave?

Sir Cliff wrote:What was the punishment that we were going to receive after Reverse kept posting from the grave?

You were due to get one of the vaunted Mayoral Powers (which never actually came in) and that never happened. Also I started removing one inactive a night until there were none left. It was a tricky one because it was a rule break, but it was hard to make a balanced punishment.

I just remembered about this:

Sentry wrote:
Descent wrote:
Sentry wrote:In past games has the vote rigger role been someone the wolves have, or is it a villager role?

Villager/Citizen/Innocents role.

OK. I was beginning to form a suspicion on someone but that completely ruins it, and so it's not worth mentioning.

I can't remember exactly who I suspected now, but I was thrown off the scent before I looked into it fully.

The information was correct at the time of writing!

Saboteur: Accounts Revealed!

Who is online

Affiliates