First of all, I'd like to say thank you to the twenty two people who nominated and the twenty people who voted. Together we've generated a list of winners which are arguably more worthy than those the Emmys claim are the best of TV. Congratulations GRcade we're better than the Emmys! In fact there was literally only one category where we came up with the same winner as the Emmys did but after a late vote that's changed.
Now to the awards!
As a means to facilitate discussion (and because I'm still writing the winning posts), I'm not going to announce all the awards at once but I will include how many votes each winner got with each reveal. In the event of the tie, I will then declare winner whomever got the most nominations. If there is still a tie, I'll either choose my favourite of the two as winner or just make all of them joint winners.
The full list of winners:
Best Drama: Breaking Bad Best Comedy: Curb your Enthusiasm Best Dramedy: Men of a Certain Age Best Actor in a Drama: Bryan Cranston (Breaking Bad) Best Actor in a Comedy: Larry David (Curb your Enthusiasm) Best Actor in a Dramedy: Louis CK (Louie) Best Actress in a Drama: Elisabeth Moss (Mad Men) Best Actress in a Comedy: Kaitlin Olsen (IASIP) Best Actress in a Dramedy: Yvonne Strahovski (Chuck) Best Supporting Actor in a drama: John Noble (Fringe) Best Supporting Actor in a comedy: J.B Smoove (Curb Your Enthusiasm) Best Supporting Actor in a dramedy: Jeremy Piven (Entourage) Best Supporting Actress in a drama: Maisie Williams (GOT) Best Supporting Actress in a comedy: Susie Essman Best Supporting Actress in a dramedy: Pamela Adlon (Louie) Best New Show: Game of Thrones Best Finale(applies to both season and series finales): Game of Thrones Best Music: Game of Thrones Most Overrated Show: True Blood Most Underrated Show: Rubicon Worst Finale: The Walking Dead Worst Actor: Chris Colfer (Glee) Worst Actress: Snorlax (Glee) and Alyson Hannigan (How I met your mother) Best Character on USTV :Leon Black (Curb Your Enthusiasm) Worst character on USTV: Tara Thornton (True Blood) Saddest Cancellation: Rubicon Ongoing show in most need of cancellation: The Simpsons
Last edited by TV Dinner on Tue Sep 20, 2011 11:40 am, edited 2 times in total.
Larry David (Curb your Enthusiasm): 32 Karl Pilkington (An Idiot Abroad/The Ricky Gervais Show): 16 Charlie Day (IASIP): 13 Ty Burrell (Modern Family): 11 Nick Offerman (Parks and Recreation): 9 Joel McHale (Community): 7 Rob McElhenney (IASIP): 6