Page 4 of 101
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – The calm before the storm (Day 0)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 8:56 am
by Gouverneur
Jennifer Lawrence wrote:Hugo Weaving wrote:There must be some form of hidden downside to the etang, because that's super powerful. Having 5 innocent people confirmed in one go would be crazy.
I realise it says it takes a day to prepare, but that means we can use it on Day 2 I assume? So essentially every 2 days we get the opportunity to effectively seer 5 people.
It's effectively more Seerings at once, with the trade-off of much less accuracy. We only get confirmed info with five good guys.
Jennifer is correct. If a single Freedom Fighter is submerged alongside any other combination of players, the Etang will glow red.
Also to clarify: while the Etang must be set up this evening and therefore cannot be used today, from tomorrow onwards it can be used every day.
Just make sure you elect a trustworthy Bourreau today. Otherwise their choice between the secret two options could hamper our prospects of tracking down the Freedom Fighters...
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 8:57 am
by Jodie Comer
Mayor Ballot:
Ryan Reynolds - Guillotine Zendaya
2 - Ryan Reynolds, Jodie Comer
Brad Pitt - Guillotine Unknown
1 - Brad Pitt
Happy with an inactive lynching for our first shot in the dark.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:01 am
by Jodie Comer
We need to elect a trustworthy mayor. We have no way of knowing that with such little information early days.
Could all Mayoral candidates confirm or deny if they are willing to be submerged in the Etang tomorrow after being elected today? RyanReynolds wrote:I
Brad Pitt wrote:.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:13 am
by Angelina Jolie
They don't need to be willing, do they? Tomorrow's Bourreau will make that decision for them.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:17 am
by Jodie Comer
Angelina Jolie wrote:They don't need to be willing, do they? Tomorrow's Bourreau will make that decision for them.
They don't need to be willing but their input now is more data for us to go on. I want to see their responses to this situation.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:23 am
by Tom Hardy
Putting everyone who stands for Bourreau in the dunk tank as a matter of course is logical. For today's execution, I would argue for either an inactive or no lynch at all if we can do that. Inactive preferable.
I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent. However as I knew that and so intentionally did not post on the first page to see who would, I'm happy to go in the dunk tank too.
Jodie Comer
Maggie Smith
Scarlett Johansson
Ana de Armas
Clint Eastwood
Jennifer Lawrence
Angelina Jolie
Jason Isaacs
Anya Taylor Joy
Bae Doona
RyanReynolds
Brad Pitt
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – The calm before the storm (Day 0)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:27 am
by karen gillan
Gouverneur wrote:Jennifer Lawrence wrote:Hugo Weaving wrote:There must be some form of hidden downside to the etang, because that's super powerful. Having 5 innocent people confirmed in one go would be crazy.
I realise it says it takes a day to prepare, but that means we can use it on Day 2 I assume? So essentially every 2 days we get the opportunity to effectively seer 5 people.
It's effectively more Seerings at once, with the trade-off of much less accuracy. We only get confirmed info with five good guys.
Jennifer is correct. If a single Freedom Fighter is submerged alongside any other combination of players, the Etang will glow red.
Also to clarify: while the Etang must be set up this evening and therefore cannot be used today, from tomorrow onwards it can be used every day.
Just make sure you elect a trustworthy Bourreau today. Otherwise their choice between the secret two options could hamper our prospects of tracking down the Freedom Fighters...
will the etang be in play for the entire game
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:28 am
by Ana de Armas
Whoever is Mayor tomorrow should be sure to dunk in any mayoral candidate that claims they'd be happy to go for a swim today.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:30 am
by Ana de Armas
Tom Hardy wrote:I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent.
Ana de Armas
I'd gladly get wet for France
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:31 am
by Tom Hardy
Ana de Armas wrote:Tom Hardy wrote:I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent.
Ana de Armas
I'd gladly get wet for France
It's a pleasure to make your acquaintance mademoiselle.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – The calm before the storm (Day 0)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:36 am
by Tilda Swinton
Hugo Weaving wrote:There must be some form of hidden downside to the etang, because that's super powerful. Having 5 innocent people confirmed in one go would be crazy.
I realise it says it takes a day to prepare, but that means we can use it on Day 2 I assume? So essentially every 2 days we get the opportunity to effectively seer 5 people.
It only says whether a revolutionary is present, so it casts suspicision on all 5 people
The catch is the increased paranoia due to lack of accuracy
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – The calm before the storm (Day 0)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:39 am
by Jason Isaacs
Gouverneur wrote:Jennifer Lawrence wrote:Hugo Weaving wrote:There must be some form of hidden downside to the etang, because that's super powerful. Having 5 innocent people confirmed in one go would be crazy.
I realise it says it takes a day to prepare, but that means we can use it on Day 2 I assume? So essentially every 2 days we get the opportunity to effectively seer 5 people.
It's effectively more Seerings at once, with the trade-off of much less accuracy. We only get confirmed info with five good guys.
Jennifer is correct. If a single Freedom Fighter is submerged alongside any other combination of players, the Etang will glow red.
Also to clarify: while the Etang must be set up this evening and therefore cannot be used today, from tomorrow onwards it can be used every day.
Just make sure you elect a trustworthy Bourreau today. Otherwise their choice between the secret two options could hamper our prospects of tracking down the Freedom Fighters...
Question regarding the Bourreau. They must submerge five people in to the Etang for it to work. Can one of the five be the Bourreau themselves?
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:39 am
by Morgan Freeman
Jodie Comer wrote:Angelina Jolie wrote:They don't need to be willing, do they? Tomorrow's Bourreau will make that decision for them.
They don't need to be willing but their input now is more data for us to go on. I want to see their responses to this situation.
The only thing that comes to mind here is false positive roles, which have been in a few games. But really we can't be inactive based on a guess like that and if there are any roles that are innocent but flag red we might just have to consider it collateral damage if we're unlucky enough to target them.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:39 am
by Keanu Reeves
I guess the flip side of the Etang is that although we know that one or more of the five people is a freedom fighter, it might take a couple of days to find them and by that point we’re at a disadvantage numbers wise. It’s an interesting game mechanic! Happy to go into it myself, by the way. I’d feel…Excellent!…about doing so.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:46 am
by RyanReynolds2
Jodie Comer wrote:We need to elect a trustworthy mayor. We have no way of knowing that with such little information early days.
Could all Mayoral candidates confirm or deny if they are willing to be submerged in the Etang tomorrow after being elected today? RyanReynolds wrote:I
Brad Pitt wrote:.
More than happy to take the plunge tomorrow and indeed I'd encourage tomorrow's mayor to put me in so you can be sure of my good intentions with regards to the set up of the pool today.
I think a good setup would be to make an initial short list of 5 people and then if there are any freedom fighters in the initial list then we can rotate new people in/out two at a time as whenever we get a switch in color from that point on it should narrow down our options to a 50/50.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:48 am
by Bryan Cranston
Early days so I've no idea who to vote for yet, maybe just an inactive. I do think a wolf might want to be mayor and so the two mayoral candidates (Ryan Reynolds and Brad Pitt) should be submerged tomorrow.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:48 am
by Scarlett Johansson
Tom Hardy wrote:Putting everyone who stands for Bourreau in the dunk tank as a matter of course is logical. For today's execution, I would argue for either an inactive or no lynch at all if we can do that. Inactive preferable.
I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent. However as I knew that and so intentionally did not post on the first page to see who would, I'm happy to go in the dunk tank too.
Jodie Comer
Maggie Smith
Scarlett Johansson
Ana de Armas
Clint Eastwood
Jennifer Lawrence
Angelina Jolie
Jason Isaacs
Anya Taylor Joy
Bae Doona
RyanReynolds
Brad Pitt
Thats just guesswork. I'm clean though. Normal villager-type role.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:50 am
by Morgan Freeman
Scarlett Johansson wrote:Tom Hardy wrote:Putting everyone who stands for Bourreau in the dunk tank as a matter of course is logical. For today's execution, I would argue for either an inactive or no lynch at all if we can do that. Inactive preferable.
I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent. However as I knew that and so intentionally did not post on the first page to see who would, I'm happy to go in the dunk tank too.
Jodie Comer
Maggie Smith
Scarlett Johansson
Ana de Armas
Clint Eastwood
Jennifer Lawrence
Angelina Jolie
Jason Isaacs
Anya Taylor Joy
Bae Doona
RyanReynolds
Brad Pitt
Thats just guesswork. I'm clean though. Normal villager-type role.
Everything is guesswork until we have something to go on. No point being inactive, we need to do something and at least this is a plan.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:51 am
by Keanu Reeves
Scarlett Johansson wrote:Tom Hardy wrote:Putting everyone who stands for Bourreau in the dunk tank as a matter of course is logical. For today's execution, I would argue for either an inactive or no lynch at all if we can do that. Inactive preferable.
I would also note however that from previous experience at least one of the posters who posted on the first page is probably a FF. So putting some of them in the other slots of the tank is prudent. However as I knew that and so intentionally did not post on the first page to see who would, I'm happy to go in the dunk tank too.
Jodie Comer
Maggie Smith
Scarlett Johansson
Ana de Armas
Clint Eastwood
Jennifer Lawrence
Angelina Jolie
Jason Isaacs
Anya Taylor Joy
Bae Doona
RyanReynolds
Brad Pitt
Thats just guesswork. I'm clean though. Normal villager-type role.
Of course it’s guesswork, but what else do you go on for day one? Established patterns and behaviour from previous games. Alt accounts doesn’t stop that, it just means “big names” don’t get killed on day one.
Re: Are You A Freedom Fighter? – Who is Jacques de Molay? (Day 1)
Posted: Mon Feb 14, 2022 9:54 am
by Zendaya
S'up, y'all! I arrived precisely when I meant to. Yup, I didn't forget at all.
Now let's get this anything goes Celebrity Big Brother started!