Are You A Werewolf? - GAME OVER

Shadow wrote:The idea was that the seer group would check them out and try to get the message out, that doesn't seem to have happened though. I don't really know why we're going after the inactives. We're just creating more loose ends when we haven’t tied up the old ones. I think Pacman is fair enough to put this platform forward, but I’m surprised it won, I don’t see why this was the most appealing platform…

They were never going to be able to do that though. Either a seer would have to reveal themselves and convince the thread that they were kosher or someone else would have to claim to be the voice of the group and do the same. They wouldn't have been wolfed but the only way to convince everyone would have been to lynch them and even then if Qikz was found to be lying again he'd probably still walk.

Okay, so here is a list of everyone who is still left in the game. 36 people. 14 of them are coloured red and that's because they either voted against lynching Rik or they stood for mayor on that same day with a different pair of candidates.



And here is everyone (still alive) who has stood for mayor:



As you can see, a disproportionate number of mayor candidates are people who did not want wolf Rik to be lynched on Day 2.
I'm not saying all the red names there are guilty and the others are innocent, but there must be some correlation.

If you think I'm the alpha that much ill do a sig bet with you. If I'm the alpha you get to make me a sig for a month. If I'm not, then I get to make you one. Deal?

I can get behind going through the guys in red. I just can't believe we've not made a real start on the Day 2 list and that we've gone for 2 inactives. I'll vote for Curls as it's obvious JChalmers is a Villager (or it's a brilliant double bluff )

Qikz wrote:If you think I'm the alpha that much ill do a sig bet with you. If I'm the alpha you get to make me a sig for a month. If I'm not, then I get to make you one. Deal?

This is the sort of thing that makes me suspect you are Dblock I can't work out if you are being overly nobbish to make everyone think "no wolf would act like that so they must be innocent" and so hiding in plain sight, or if you are just being a nob

Qikz wrote:If you think I'm the alpha that much ill do a sig bet with you. If I'm the alpha you get to make me a sig for a month. If I'm not, then I get to make you one. Deal?

I wasn't even accusing you

Here is a summary:

Firstly, three key points:
- The wolves have been killing very active players.
- We are nine days in so the wolves must have run for mayor several times now.
- The wolves did not want Riksilver lynched on Day 2.

Now when you look back to see which mayors have not been killed yet, and compare that with the list of people who didn't want to lynch Riksilver there is a clear overlap.

Some of those red names are wolves!

Not you satriales. PCCD.

I probably won't be around tonight so if I don't survive, avenge me.

Don't think there's anything particularly strong on either of these guys other than the activity tier they fall under. I guess I'll be lynching Curls since he seems perhaps the more likely wolf, but there's not much in it.

I have absolutely no clue who I'm meant to be voting to lynch tonight. Where they've been so inactive, similarly there's very little evidence on them.

JChalmers defense has me convinced. Sorry Curls.

I don't think either of these guys were wolves though.

These guys are villagers we all know that yet we continue with it.

I saw Zellery and Parksey both in pm section exact same time yet you wouldn't vote for me.

Bullshit g\ame

Dblock wrote:These guys are villagers we all know that yet we continue with it.

I saw Zellery and Parksey both in pm section exact same time yet you wouldn't vote for me.

Bullshit g\ame

Why is this the first time you've mentioned this the entire game? o_O

Also when did you see them on there?

It's actually not. He mentioned it earlier today but everyone just skipped over it. Probably because they assumed he was just spouting bullshit like usual. I got a telling off from MiniE for calling him out and pointing out it was dumb luck that Rik was wolf running on that logic.

But it remains: why did he only mention it today?

Qikz wrote:Not you satriales. PCCD.

I don't recall accusing you of being the alpha either. I made an observation about the seers being unable to come forward and that was it.

PCCD wrote:

Qikz wrote:Not you satriales. PCCD.

I don't recall accusing you of being the alpha either. I made an observation about the seers being unable to come forward and that was it.

I'm just not going to bother posting from my phone from now on, because I can't seem to read what's on the screen. Either that or I'm reading in a rush or something. Nevermind then.

Qikz wrote:

Dblock wrote:These guys are villagers we all know that yet we continue with it.

I saw Zellery and Parksey both in pm section exact same time yet you wouldn't vote for me.

Bullshit g\ame

Why is this the first time you've mentioned this the entire game? o_O

I believe this is actually the third time he's mentioned it. This isn't new information.

I voted Pancake as I felt all the other potential lynchees were most likely villager, but also partly because it's not a tactic we've tried yet and it could potentially yeild new info. However I have no idea what to think about either JChalmers or Curls, but since I voted for mayor I should vote in the lynch and I'm going fro JChalmers as I can't believe a wolf would say nothing in their defence which seems to be the case with Curls.

How is it we've killed 3 wolves and don't have any new leads from it?

Luke_25 wrote:How is it we've killed 3 wolves and don't have any new leads from it?

Because all three kills were essentially just getting lucky without any real evidence lol

Vig got lucky that Rik flipped wolf honestly. Just because he turned out to be a wolf doesn't make it a great play.
Devlin just got name dropped by jiggles on a hunch with very little evidence.
Songwriter got found guilty by a seer.

So it's not really surprising there's no evidence considering we haven't actually caught any wolves yet