Are You A Werewolf? - GAME OVER

Going to vote Kanbei because the case against Tomous is so tenuous (I feel you bro) and since Kanbei hasn't been posting much it's not like we're losing much if he goes down, whereas with Tom he's proving himself to be an active participant so he's more useful to us in the long run.

Been catching up with the thread and noticed a few times people saying we haven't had a great start. Unless I'm missing something then we had the second best possible start (ignoring the possibility of a lucky vigi kill).

So it could have been better if we had lynched a wolf but at least we didn't lynch a special role either.
The wolf kills were all normal, inactive villagers so we couldn't have done any better at all there.

So far, so good!

PaperMacheMario wrote:Christ, I'm scared of posting if that is what Tomous is being lynched for tonight. I know there isn't much to go on but I'd rather lynch an inactive than an active who's proved really useful in the previous game.

I don't get the idea of lynching inactives, the wolves are not going to be inactive bit amongst the moderate posters. Lynching inactives is just wasting our little bit of power.

It's a shame we lose good people, but we are at a massive advantage if we hit a wolf early.

Moggy wrote:I don't get the idea of lynching inactives, the wolves are not going to be inactive.

I'd guess there's probably a mix amongst the wolves - a couple of low key posters, a couple of high-profile and the rest in the middle. There is only 1 totally inactive player left anyway.

I'm not voting as there's no convincing arguments.

In past games when ive looked at the spread of wolves in post numbers, Ive mostly noticed:

Very Very high posters - 0 wolves
High posters - 1 wolf (usually the alpha)
Medium posters - 2 wolves
Semi-active - 3 wolves
inactive - maybe the 1 wolf that gets caught early

However that is usually when the policy of lynching inactives is touted, thus driving the wolves to post, and perhaps making mistakes. So if we start lynching semi active or medium posters, do we drive the wolves to post less and make less mistakes?

As a caveat to this is that the special roles tend to bunch both closer to the high and inactive areas, but again that might be because they either try stay anonymous or are outed and have to do damage limitation.

I'm not voting as both are not wolves.

You all have been played.

Mini-e run but you can't hide.

Dblock wrote:I'm not voting as both are not wolves.

You all have been played.

Mini-e run but you can't hide.

You realise I'm not the Mayor and I backed Pacman's manifesto even though I didn't vote for it? But I shall keep running away

Mini E wrote:

Dblock wrote:I'm not voting as both are not wolves.

You all have been played.

Mini-e run but you can't hide.

You realise I'm not the Mayor and I backed Pacman's manifesto even though I didn't vote for it? But I shall keep running away

Cause you know he is killing villagers and want to keep your hands clean.

I'll hunt you as long as i'm in the game, and if i get killed read my posts!

Have fun

The deadline for voting has now passed!

Who will be Day 2's sacrifice? Find out at 9pm!

Dblock wrote:
I'll hunt you as long as i'm in the game, and if i get killed read my posts!

Hunt? Like a wolf you mean?

I'm onto you Derek.

Derek is the Village Idiot role whether it was assigned to him or not.

I've only just noticed that I'm up for this been busy the last couple of days and haven't had time to go through everything!

I know the vote is done already, but I don't really like the fact that so many people wanted me out this early. I've been a good player on both sides before (I was a wolf under Mini E's alphaship twice before and he remarked upon how good the strategy I made up was) and it seems like I'm being killed to get me out very quickly. I hope I do survive the night and manage to go on a few more days

Less to catch up on than I expected.

I can live with this. Seems like good observational skills on whoever has picked up on Tomous's slip up.

Clarkman wrote:Less to catch up on than I expected.

I can live with this. Seems like good observational skills on whoever has picked up on Tomous's slip up.

Is it still good observational skills if he comes back a villager?

Zellery wrote:

Clarkman wrote:Less to catch up on than I expected.

I can live with this. Seems like good observational skills on whoever has picked up on Tomous's slip up.

Is it still good observational skills if he comes back a villager?

If they were a wolf

Kanbei wrote:I've only just noticed that I'm up for this been busy the last couple of days and haven't had time to go through everything!

I know the vote is done already, but I don't really like the fact that so many people wanted me out this early. I've been a good player on both sides before (I was a wolf under Mini E's alphaship twice before and he remarked upon how good the strategy I made up was) and it seems like I'm being killed to get me out very quickly. I hope I do survive the night and manage to go on a few more days

Nobody particularly wanted you out. We just don't have much to go on and you haven't done anything despite having previous good form!

Everybody is guilty until proven innocent in this thing.

Pancake wrote:

Kanbei wrote:I've only just noticed that I'm up for this been busy the last couple of days and haven't had time to go through everything!

I know the vote is done already, but I don't really like the fact that so many people wanted me out this early. I've been a good player on both sides before (I was a wolf under Mini E's alphaship twice before and he remarked upon how good the strategy I made up was) and it seems like I'm being killed to get me out very quickly. I hope I do survive the night and manage to go on a few more days

Nobody particularly wanted you out. We just don't have much to go on and you haven't done anything despite having previous good form!

Everybody is guilty until proven innocent in this thing.

It's the 2nd day

Also, everyone knows that most of the stuff in this game happens behind the scenes. Just because you aren't active in thread, doesn't mean you are inactive.

I do not like the way that people seem happy with getting rid of a good player (I hope people agree with me on this) with no evidence whatsoever.

Pretty sure with my mayorship you weren't going. I wanted Rik out (sorry Rik )