'Are You A Werewolf? - The Final Lynch? p374

Mockmaster wrote:Bit of a random question, but do any of the wolves have the real life first name of John?

I do.

Mockmaster wrote:Bit of a random question, but do any of the wolves have the real life first name of John?

Yep!

Why do you ask?

Henke wrote:

Mockmaster wrote:Bit of a random question, but do any of the wolves have the real life first name of John?

I do.

My god.

Mockmaster wrote:

Henke wrote:

Mockmaster wrote:Bit of a random question, but do any of the wolves have the real life first name of John?

I do.

My god.

Not really though. Although judging by JK's reaction his name might be John.

JK wrote:

Mockmaster wrote:Bit of a random question, but do any of the wolves have the real life first name of John?

Yep!

Why do you ask?

My god.

This is very important, John. Are you the only wolf that has that real life name?

No Mockmaster, you are the demons.

I will find you, John.

I don't understand what's happening.

Clarkman wrote:As a wolf that is

Yum yum humans. Yeah, I've never won as a human though. I wasn't suspected all through that game except for at the end with the obvious giveaway thanks to being a damn Commander.

AND I WON AS CAPTAIN.

I always suspected you because of that MSN you sent me on the very first day, but I died before I actually began to play so you got off the hook.

Right, a few things I've been wanting to get off my chest, and since this game finally over I now have the platform to do so.

Firstly, well done to the wolves. You were however NOT without fault (more on that later), and I think this will probably be the easiest win a pack will see for a long, long time.

Secondly, I have some feedback for you, DML. The game was horribly unbalanced from the off. Nine Werewolves and just two Seers, with an extra Vigilante thrown in for good measure was really, really handicapping us. That was more wolves than ever by at least two, and one Seer less, with an added vigilante just for good measure. Coupled with the bridge system which severely limited our options, I had trouble seeing anything but a wolf win, and when they started taking out big players from the off, sadly it was all a matter of time, which brings me to my next point.

Never, ever should the werewolves have been allowed to pick off the actives, and in some cases the most effective players right from the beginning. All credit to the wolves here, I'd have done the exact same, but that should never have been allowed to happen, and an already unbalanced game started to become one way traffic.

Thirdly, the villagers, after myself, Denster, Hexx, Herbi, Mocky, Stu etc were killed, absolutely the most ABYSMAL performance I've ever seen, even more so towards the end. I mean for the final week it was abundantly clear that Clarkman, Henke, Krafty and especially Mori were wolves. You let them just take control without ever really questioning anything, and I put that down partially to the fact there were so many inactives and first timers remaining. I had Mori down as a wolf from what, Day 2? When I contacted Eighthours with the FE, Nood and Mori scenario, and unfortunately he elected to stick the other two up for lynching. I mean come on! He posted drivel after drivel without ever really doing or saying anything helpful!

I was actually contacted by someone a week ago after posting in the thread, asking if I was interested in who the wolves were. I responded by guessing with my seven likeliest suspects. The four listed above were included.

Again, I don't think this would have been so bad had DML disallowed the merciless killing of big names from the start, thus all that were left towards the end was a mix of wolves and inactives, with a few semi-active humans left alive.

Memento Mori wrote:I was the most trusted human there for a significant portion of the game.

Only because you had a completely useless set of humans in front of you who couldn't spot a werewolf for the life of 'em.

Even so, I must applaud DML for putting together an entertaining game for a short period of time. Back to basics next time please with a player cap.

I remember when I said to Aaron the day after i'd spoke to Clarkman something along the lines of... "If I die tonight, do everything you can to get Clarkman killed"

Never happened...

Drumstick wrote:Never, ever should the werewolves have been allowed to pick off the actives, and in some cases the most effective players right from the beginning. All credit to the wolves here, I'd have done the exact same, but that should never have been allowed to happen, and an already unbalanced game started to become one way traffic.

DML Handicapped us to Inactives for the first three nights.
Or - as it turned out - near inactives, as there were very, very few genuine inactives around the first three days.

After that he said the leash was off and we went after the poirot's, Columbo's and Kojak's of the game.

LewisD wrote:

Drumstick wrote:Never, ever should the werewolves have been allowed to pick off the actives, and in some cases the most effective players right from the beginning. All credit to the wolves here, I'd have done the exact same, but that should never have been allowed to happen, and an already unbalanced game started to become one way traffic.

DML Handicapped us to Inactives for the first three nights.
Or - as it turned out - near inactives, as there were very, very few genuine inactives around the first three days.

After that he said the leash was off and we went after the poirot's, Columbo's and Kojak's of the game.

First two nights wasn't it?

Drumstick wrote: He [Memento Mori] posted drivel after drivel without ever really doing or saying anything helpful!

That's how he posts just in general though.

Gotta say, I'm confused by this "john" thing?

When's the next game of this then?

We need to try and convince Commshep

a) To come back
b) to start another AYAW with truck eating wolves

Terminator references, me thinks?

Drumstick wrote:Right, a few things I've been wanting to get off my chest, and since this game finally over I now have the platform to do so.

Firstly, well done to the wolves. You were however NOT without fault (more on that later), and I think this will probably be the easiest win a pack will see for a long, long time.

Secondly, I have some feedback for you, DML. The game was horribly unbalanced from the off. Nine Werewolves and just two Seers, with an extra Vigilante thrown in for good measure was really, really handicapping us. That was more wolves than ever by at least two, and one Seer less, with an added vigilante just for good measure. Coupled with the bridge system which severely limited our options, I had trouble seeing anything but a wolf win, and when they started taking out big players from the off, sadly it was all a matter of time, which brings me to my next point.

Never, ever should the werewolves have been allowed to pick off the actives, and in some cases the most effective players right from the beginning. All credit to the wolves here, I'd have done the exact same, but that should never have been allowed to happen, and an already unbalanced game started to become one way traffic.

Thirdly, the villagers, after myself, Denster, Hexx, Herbi, Mocky, Stu etc were killed, absolutely the most ABYSMAL performance I've ever seen, even more so towards the end. I mean for the final week it was abundantly clear that Clarkman, Henke, Krafty and especially Mori were wolves. You let them just take control without ever really questioning anything, and I put that down partially to the fact there were so many inactives and first timers remaining. I had Mori down as a wolf from what, Day 2? When I contacted Eighthours with the FE, Nood and Mori scenario, and unfortunately he elected to stick the other two up for lynching. I mean come on! He posted drivel after drivel without ever really doing or saying anything helpful!

I was actually contacted by someone a week ago after posting in the thread, asking if I was interest in who the wolves were. I responded by guessing with my seven likeliest suspects. The four listed above were included.

Again, I don't think this would have been so bad had DML disallowed the merciless killing of big names from the start, thus all that were left towards the end was a mix of wolves and inactives, with a few semi-active humans left alive.

Memento Mori wrote:I was the most trusted human there for a significant portion of the game.

Only because you had a completely useless set of humans in front of you who couldn't spot a werewolf for the life of 'em.

Even so, I must applaud DML for putting together an entertaining game for a short period of time. Back to basics next time please with a player cap.

I agree with pretty much all of this, I do think DML listened to us when we asked for a back to basics AYAW though as aside from the bridge thing that's what this was. It's just a shame that the Bridge system and the wolves screwed the villagers over as much as they did.

Mini E wrote:We need to try and convince Commshep

a) To come back
b) to start another AYAW with truck eating wolves

He came back for our msn celebrations.

EDIT: Drummy, thing is there were a lot of reasons why things went wrong for the humans from the start. In my opinion a lot of it had to do with the needless arguing going on in the thread and a few choice individuals who seemed to go out of their way to spam up the thread and distract from us.