[Red Tribe chat] TRIBE VS TRIBE

[Cuttooth]

I’m not sure if we’re having shocking luck or if Nun’s bared his arse somehow and got caught. It’s intensely frustrating.

I think we were ridiculously unlucky to have two of us in the dock on day one and two to be honest.

[RetroCora]

Very happy to look seriously at just naming the rest of the teams now and slapping a protection on mic or Cutty. We’re right up against it now, our only choice really is to try and convince the other teams that we’re flailing and not worth going for. Which, to be fair, isn’t exactly a lie.

[Herdanos]

A MEMBER OF YOUR TRIBE HAS BEEN ELIMINATED

Nun has been eliminated from the game.
Please do not talk to Nun about the game, for the remainder of the game.
This applies to any and all channels of communication (WhatsApp, Discord etc).
If they are a member of any chat groups or similar please can you now remove them.

Couple of quick questions Dan - did we get a kill yesterday, and can you double protect someone?

You didn't get a kill as you didn't all post.

Yes you can apply two Saves to a player if you wish.

[RetroCora]

Cheers babes.

I think we apply one to Cutty, what do you guys reckon?

[RetroCora]

Also might be worth outing Karl as a vigilante.

[Herdanos]

You do only currently have one Save available, from 2nd and 3rd October.

[Cuttooth]

Very happy to look seriously at just naming the rest of the teams now and slapping a protection on mic or Cutty. We’re right up against it now, our only choice really is to try and convince the other teams that we’re flailing and not worth going for. Which, to be fair, isn’t exactly a lie.

You know what shall I just blow it all up and name everyone?

[RetroCora]

Very happy to look seriously at just naming the rest of the teams now and slapping a protection on mic or Cutty. We’re right up against it now, our only choice really is to try and convince the other teams that we’re flailing and not worth going for. Which, to be fair, isn’t exactly a lie.

You know what shall I just blow it all up and name everyone?

Make it so.

[Cuttooth]

Tempted to vote myself Red Tribe first.

[Cuttooth]

Post is primed and ready to go. I figure once Dan reveals I'm Red Tribe I'll send it out.

No going back for any of us after this.

[RetroCora]

Tempted to vote myself Red Tribe first.

It may be worth doing a bit of a megapost and confirming how we know what we know. Here's all the player lists that aren't from our tribe, along with the bolded players who ruled them out of winning as far as we were concerned.

Ironhide:
Mic - Vigilantes
Sprouty - Tribal Yer Eyes Mate
Parksey - Pro Village
Tsunade - Vigilantes
Vermilion - Red Tribe
Curls - Pro Village
Rocsteady - Pro Village
Frank - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate

Aaron - we eliminated this one based on Aaron as a member of TYEM going for their streak
Drumstick - TYEM
ORKN - TYEM
Curls - TYEM
Aayl1 - TYEM
Vermillion - TYEM
Pedz - TYEM
Qikz - TYEM
Tsunade - TYEM

Tsunade:
Sprouty - Red Tribe
Ob Bob - Vigilantes
Jenuall - TYEM
Mic - Pro-Village
Nun - TYEM
DML - Vigilantes
DarkRula - Pro-Village
Curls – Vigilantes

Vermilion
Sprouty - Pro Village
Ob Bob - Vigilantes
mic - Pro Village
Drumstick - Red Tribe
Qikz - Vigilantes
Aayl1 - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Tsunade - Red Tribe
Nun - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate

Pedz - lol
Qikz - Pro-Village
Oblomov Boblomov - vigilante
Jenuall - Red Tribe
Ironhide - Red Tribe
site23 - Tribe YER EYES Mate
DML - Tribe Yer Eyes Mates
Cuttooth - Pro-village
RetroCora – Vigilante

Drum
Sprouty - Red Tribe
Pedz - Vigis
Sprouty - Red Tribe
Retro Cora - Pro-Village
mic - Vigis
DML - Pro-Village
Preezy - Vigis
Vermi - TYEM

Roon
DML - Vigilantes
Vermillion - TYEM
Preezy - Red Tribe
Pedz - Vigilantes
aayl1 - TYEM
DarkRula - Red Tribe
Tsunade - Vigilantes
Drumstick - Pro-Village

Hypes
Preezy Pro-Village
Oblomov Boblomov - Pro-Village
aayl1 - TRIBE YER EYES MATE
OrangeRKN - TRIBE YER EYES MATE
DML - Red Tribe
Nun - Vigilantes
Roonmastor - Vigilantes
SuperChris - Vigilantes

Rula
Oblomov Boblomov - Vigilantes
Roonmastor - Vigilantes
mic - Pro-Village
RetroCora - Pro-Village
Hypes - Red Tribe
Cuttooth - Red Tribe
Vermilion - TYEM
Tsunade - TYEM

Qikz
Oblomov Boblomov - Pro Village
DML - Vigilantes
Parksey - Red Tribe - incorrect
SuperChris - Red Tribe
DarkRula - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Pedz - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Preezy - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Tsunade - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate

Frank
Vermilion - TYEM
SuperChris - Vigilantes
Pedz - Vigilantes
Jenuall - Pro-Village
Ironhide - Vigilantes
Cuttooth - TYEM
Tsundae - TYEM
Mic – Vigilantes

Ob
Jenuall - Red Tribe
Ironhide - Red Tribe
site23 - Vigilantes
DML - Vigilantes
Vermilion - TYEM
Parksey - TYEM
OrangeRKN - Pro-Village
Drumstick - Pro-Village

Parksey - confirmed not vigilantes
DarkRula - Vigilantes
Drumstick - Vigilantes
Ironhide - Vigilantes
Jenuall - Vigilantes
Pedz - Vigilantes
Rocsteady - Vigilantes
Roonmastor - Vigilantes
Sawyerpip – Vigilantes

Sawyerpip
Pedz - Vigilantes
Nun - Pro-Village
Hypes - TYEM
Cuttooth - Red Tribe
Jenuall - Vigilantes
Vermilion - Pro-Village
DarkRula - TYEM
mic - Red Tribe

Jenuall
SuperChris - Red Tribe
Vermilion - TYEM
Tsunade - Vigilantes
Preezy - TYEM
mic - Red Tribe
RetroCora - Vigilantes
Nun - Pro-Village
Pedz – Vigilantes

Karl
Drumstick - Pro-Village
RetroCora - Pro-Village
Preezy - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Vermilion - Tribe Yer Eyes Mate
Parksey - Red Tribe
SuperChris - Red Tribe
DML - Vigilantes
Sawyerpip - Vigilantes

[Cuttooth]

I've never actually made a megaton post in any of these games before.

Do you want me to effectively just post that along with the full list of everyone (including us) as showing my workings?

[RetroCora]

I've never actually made a megaton post in any of these games before.

Do you want me to effectively just post that along with the full list of everyone (including us) as showing my workings?

Let me see if I can get a post together that shows our workings out - it'll be after the Celtic game, but I'll post it in here ASAP and then you can use it as you wish!

[RetroCora]

Actually belay that, I forgot I have my weekly quiz league match tonight. Sorry mate

Just go with what you feel is right, we'll back you.

[Cuttooth]

No worries.

[RetroCora]

I really hope we are right about this, or we're gonna look very stupid.

[Cuttooth]

Yeah that's my fear since it's going to reveal you three as well.

[Cuttooth]

I really hope we are right about this, or we're gonna look very stupid.

How confident are you about this?

[Cuttooth]

I want a couple of posts celebrating this first...

[RetroCora]

I really hope we are right about this, or we're gonna look very stupid.

How confident are you about this?

As sure as we're going to be. We know for 100% fact the following, due to the Qikz vigilante list win:

Pro Village - Ob Bob
Vigilantes - DML
TYEM - Rula, Pedz, Preezy, Tsunade

I confronted Preezy about this, and Preezy confirmed he was TYEM but refused to confirm the rest of his team.

Through process of elimination, we realised that Sprout was right about a team posting to keep the streak, but it was TYEM, not Vigilantes. TYEM shot Mori(again confirmed by Preezy), presumably to put people off the scent.

So that gives us everyone in TYEM - Rula, Preezy, Tsunade, Pedz, Aayl1 and Vermilion.

Now for PV. I've been discussing the game with Drum for some time, and he believed that one of mic, myself or Frank. Looking at the lists, we deduced that Frank and I hadn't really hit on much, so we believed that Drum had focused on mic's list. We're sure enough that Drum isn't Vigilante or he wouldn't have mentioned Qikz to me as a potential suspect, it would've been a needless risk. As we had been discussing an alliance against the vigilantes, and we knew Drum wasn't Red Tribe or TYEM, he is highly likely to be Pro-Village. Here are the three lists, FWIW:

Mic:
Qikz - Vigi
Ironhide - Vigi
Vermilion - TYEM
Odd Bob - TYEM
Parksey - P-V
Frank - P-V
Tsunade - RT
Preezy - RT

Frank:
Vermilion - TYEM
SuperChris - Vigilantes
Pedz - Vigilantes
Jenuall - Pro-Village
Ironhide - Vigilantes
Cuttooth - TYEM
Tsundae - TYEM
Mic – Vigilantes

Me:
Drumstick - Pro-Village
DML - Pro-Village
Site23 - Pro-Village
Vermilion - TYEM
Aayl1 - TYEM
Superchris - Red Tribe
DarkRula - Red Tribe
Ironhide - Vigilantes

Pedz also got his list entirely wrong, confirming DML as not being in TYEM and therefore confirming him as a vigilante. Him and Mori were the only non-TYEM posters in the silence task, giving the win to Pro-Village.

Some of our suspicions were further confirmed with the vote from Monday, which had the following points - 4 for PV, 2 for TYEM and 1 for us. Of the seven who voted, I was one and Verm/Pedz are both TYEM confirmed through their silence play. So the other four voters - Parksey, Hypes, Frank and Jenuall - must be PV. So now we have:

Pro-Village - Frank, Parksey, Hypes, Jenuall, Ob Bob
TYEM - Rula, Preezy, Tsunade, Pedz, Aayl1 and Vermilion.

Assuming Drum hasn't been playing a mental shell game, he completes PV. So by process of elimination, knowing all of the other tribes' identities, we have this:

Pro Village - Frank, Parksey, Hypes, Jenuall, Ob Bob, Drumstick
TYEM - Rula, Preezy, Tsunade, Pedz, Aayl1, Vermilion
Vigilantes - Ironhide, Site23, DML, Rocsteady, Sawyerpip, Roonmastor, Qikz (everyone else)
Red Tribe - ya bois

And that's how we've gotten to where we are. If this makes sense to you, and you're confident that our working out is right, go with it. As far as I'm concerned, the only potential issue is Drumstick mixed with *a random Vigilante member* is a possibility. Everything else seems pretty cast iron. But it's your call man!