Abacus wrote:Good points, and obviously I don't have the answers anyway.
What I was thinking was, keep necessary students like medics going back.
For the rest, offer a kind of national service, like working at Track & Trace or delivering stuff to shielding people that need them, on a basic wage.
It would be something for the CV anyway, and buy them in rather than have them as scapegoats.
I don't know about crunching two years together, and this might not all be done by September either, both true.
But I can think of worse plans, like encouraging people to go, trapping them all in halls together where they are more likely to catch an infectious disease, giving them a far shitier education (and remote learning is certainly worse) and then demonising them for it.
As far as I'm aware there is already a major sense of unfairness from arts students who are being charged the same nine grand for four contact hours per week and a list of books as medics who get thirty plus contact hours including practical sessions plus placements etc. Telling them to strawberry float off because they're not essential would not go down well
. Private Eye also had a lot of stuff covering how lecturing unions weren't happy about the risk of lecturers losing the rights over any filmed lectures, and arts and humanities lecturers may be feeling quite at risk about that (all lecturers probably will be, but perhaps those ones moreso than ones in degrees where you need to be professionally registered to work and there's more money floating about in general).
It's also not true to call degrees unnecessary. The NHS has over a million staff but it doesn't have a million medicine degrees. I work in ophthalmology with a lot of people who have photography undergraduate degrees. That would probably be pretty high on most "pointless degree" lists, but that just shows how wrong those lists can be. My boss has a politics degree. My wife works in the NHS and has an English degree.
I'd also say that flooding track and trace with a load of disgruntled conscripts with no life experience wouldn't help improve the effectiveness of the service, but as we all know there are larger issues present there!