Edge 213 Scores

I just don't get Edge, there seems to be no middle ground with them, they either give blatatently high scores or low scores to make a point.

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying.

consolegaming wrote:There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying.

The result, or that someone actually made it?

consolegaming wrote:There was my comprehension of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying.

Fixed

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:

consolegaming wrote:There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying.

The result, or that someone actually made it?

The results, its odd how so many 360 exclusives get 9s and 10s when the public opinion is that the games aren't actually that good. The Halo series is a prime example of a game way, way, way overrated and certainly not an Edge 10. The thing is you cannot be harsh on some games and then happy to give out 10s and 9s to others, its a disgrace.

I assume by "public opinion" you mean "your opinion"?

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:I assume by "public opinion" you mean "your opinion"?

Okay, well how many of you thing Halo 2 is a 9 and Halo 3 a 10, honestly?

consolegaming wrote:

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:I assume by "public opinion" you mean "your opinion"?

Okay, well how many of you thing Halo 2 is a 9 and Halo 3 a 10, honestly?

A video games forum =/= the general public.

consolegaming wrote:

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:I assume by "public opinion" you mean "your opinion"?

Okay, well how many of you thing Halo 2 is a 9 and Halo 3 a 10, honestly?

I don't agree with that personally but I'd definitely say most gamers would agree.

consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

Mafro wrote:consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

You know I play on my 360 more yeah?!

I just question some of their 360 scores and because I own both consoles have a more valid opinion that the 90% of GRCade residents.

consolegaming wrote:

Mafro wrote:consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

You know I play on my 360 more yeah?!

I just question some of their 360 scores and because I own both consoles have a more valid opinion that the 90% of GRCade residents.

I think you'll find the vast, vast majority of people here own all 3 consoles. I did, for a couple of years.

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:

consolegaming wrote:

Mafro wrote:consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

You know I play on my 360 more yeah?!

I just question some of their 360 scores and because I own both consoles have a more valid opinion that the 90% of GRCade residents.

I think you'll find the vast, vast majority of people here own all 3 consoles. I did, for a couple of years.

consolegaming wrote:

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:

consolegaming wrote:

Mafro wrote:consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

You know I play on my 360 more yeah?!

I just question some of their 360 scores and because I own both consoles have a more valid opinion that the 90% of GRCade residents.

I think you'll find the vast, vast majority of people here own all 3 consoles. I did, for a couple of years.

Very serious.

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying

I wouldn't worry the explanation is simple, Microsoft have delivered better games.

Rik wrote:

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying

I wouldn't worry the explanation is simple, Microsoft have delivered better games.

Not in my opinion they haven't, some of them are just plain overrated. Didn't Edge say something like they expect PS3 games to be beyond Xbox 360 games which is why they are reviewed more harshly?

consolegaming wrote:

Mafro wrote:consolegaming needs a name change to sonygaming.

You know I play on my 360 more yeah?!

I just question some of their 360 scores and because I own both consoles have a more valid opinion that the 90% of GRCade residents.

"I'm not racist, I've got black friends"

consolegaming wrote:

Rik wrote:

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying

I wouldn't worry the explanation is simple, Microsoft have delivered better games.

Not in my opinion they haven't, some of them are just plain overrated. Didn't Edge say something like they expect PS3 games to be beyond Xbox 360 games which is why they are reviewed more harshly?

And there we have the operative words. In Edge's opinion(s), they have.

Opinions are like arseholes: Everyone has one, and they're usually full of gooseberry fool.

consolegaming wrote:

Rik wrote:

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying

I wouldn't worry the explanation is simple, Microsoft have delivered better games.

Not in my opinion they haven't, some of them are just plain overrated. Didn't Edge say something like they expect PS3 games to be beyond Xbox 360 games which is why they are reviewed more harshly?

I haven't found that quote

Rik wrote:

consolegaming wrote:

Rik wrote:

There was a comparison of Xbox 360 Vs PS3 scores and thats worrying

I wouldn't worry the explanation is simple, Microsoft have delivered better games.

Not in my opinion they haven't, some of them are just plain overrated. Didn't Edge say something like they expect PS3 games to be beyond Xbox 360 games which is why they are reviewed more harshly?

I haven't found that quote

Something like that or Edge saying they expect PS3 games to be more advanced or something?

consolegaming wrote:

Somebody Else's Problem wrote:I assume by "public opinion" you mean "your opinion"?

Okay, well how many of you thing Halo 2 is a 9 and Halo 3 a 10, honestly?

What does Metacritic say?
Halo 2 = 95
Halo 3 = 94

Where does this leave your arguament?