[Vigilantes chat] TRIBE VS TRIBE

[site23]

Are we deliberately not having anyone vote with Clarkman on this? I'm kind of tempted to have one of us do it (and I'm happy to do it!) but I wanted to ask first...!

Also, I think if you add up Clarkman's posts he's basically confirmed he's in the same tribe as Tsunade (and maybe Cora) which might be a handy tidbit for us one day.

EDIT: He's unlikely to slip up any further on that though because Nun has just pointed it out to him directly. He seems to think he's in Phoenix Wright. "OBJECTION! You seem to be on the verge of a big mistake! Would you... confirm that for me?" Oh well.

[sawyerpip]

Are we deliberately not having anyone vote with Clarkman on this? I'm kind of tempted to have one of us do it (and I'm happy to do it!) but I wanted to ask first...!

We haven't really discussed it, I don't think it's a deliberate tactic or anything. I was tempted to vote that way myself, I guess atm the main thing is to not all vote together as the majority looks like it will be a low amount so not many points being dished out if it is correct.

[sawyerpip]

Are we deliberately not having anyone vote with Clarkman on this? I'm kind of tempted to have one of us do it (and I'm happy to do it!) but I wanted to ask first...!

Also, I think if you add up Clarkman's posts he's basically confirmed he's in the same tribe as Tsunade (and maybe Cora) which might be a handy tidbit for us one day.

EDIT: He's unlikely to slip up any further on that though because Nun has just pointed it out to him directly. He seems to think he's in Phoenix Wright. "OBJECTION! You seem to be on the verge of a big mistake! Would you... confirm that for me?" Oh well.

Yeah, I'd lean towards Tsundade and Clarkman being the same tribe. I'm less convinced on Cora and his explanation has kind of won me over.

I'm trying to keep observations etc. noted on the theory tab on the spreadsheet but I feel like it could get messy on there very quickly

In case it is not obvious:

Red - confirmed not that tribe
Orange - theorised not to be that tribe

Not on there yet but green would be confirmed member of a tribe, and some other colour would be suspected member of that tribe. There are also comments added if you highlight certain cells. Also everyone should have editing permission so feel free to add things as the game progresses.

[Roonmastor]

I did it, as I followed him earlier in the thread.

Also, we have zero in that group so we are well hidden if it is correct, but won't fall too far back on points.

I'm not sure which tactic to use here:

1) Vote Mommy for TYEM. Slightly better odds if you consider we've already eliminated one person from being in the tribe, so the points payoff is marginally better.

2) Vote Mommy (and every suspect) for Red Tribe. If I stick to the same tribe every time that's a 1/3 chance of some points while trying to minimise info I'm giving the thread on my own tribe. Might be too obvious a tactic though to draw attention and people could reasonably infer I'm not in Red Tribe and have a 50/50 read on me.

3) Alternate votes evenly between all 4 tribes. 1/4 days have a zero chance of scoring points but it gives nothing away about my allegiance.

4) Don't vote and give nothing away.

I think on typing it out and reflecting I'm leaning (3), which means I should go for one of PV, TYEM or V today. TYEM has the better odds on an otherwise free choice so I might go with that!

Current plan is option 5 - alternate between two tribes, one of which is ours. Obvs, this will no doubt fall apart over time.

[sawyerpip]

It it stays like this I'm going to be so tempted to make it a tie right before the deadline

[sawyerpip]

Clarkman just switched to voting for Vigilantes

[Qikz]

Clarkman just switched to voting for Vigilantes

I mean I guess he's either in the same tribe as Mommy and is trying to throw people off or he just doesn't have any idea either.

I still don't really feel like anyone has anything to go off at this point. The opening stages of the game we might as well just randomly vote constantly.

[Ironhide]

Unsure if my maniacal vote switch had any bearing on what happened or not.

[sawyerpip]

Unsure if my maniacal vote switch had any bearing on what happened or not.

Who knows, I did enjoy you putting the cat amongst the pigeons My late vote somehow got missed off the final tally in the chaos, no need to draw attention to it I guess.

So if Clarkman was telling the truth then Mommy is PV, and Clarkman (and probably Tsunade) are either TYEM or RT, and significantly with the Vigilante result the tribe they are not a member of out of TYEM and RT can now deduce they are a member of the other. Alternatively this was some strange public play to try and convince the thread that those actively arguing against each other can't possibly be the same tribe? Or perhaps they realised last minute that too much information would be given away in the points if PV had won the vote and decided to change tact?

Too many scenarios to consider

.

.

Just a final reminder to try and post before midnight if you can. I think all other players have posted today.

[site23]

Don't worry, I'll get a post in later - being deliberately a bit lurky - but thanks for the reminder!

[Ironhide]

Unsure if my maniacal vote switch had any bearing on what happened or not.

Who knows, I did enjoy you putting the cat amongst the pigeons My late vote somehow got missed off the final tally in the chaos, no need to draw attention to it I guess.

I won't be making a habit of doing that, just felt like having a laugh.

[Roonmastor]

If you guess right and your guess wins, you will receive Victory Points.

Not enough respect for this.

I didn't need to click the link to know what was behind it. How sad does that make me?

(Just went abroad for the weekend with my mates solely to play board games with the aim to win a board game trophy I bought and engraved, so about that sad).

[Roonmastor]

Just caught up. Angry at Clarkman so let's interrogate him.

[sawyerpip]

Is anyone going to be around for the contest at 12pm in case it is time-sensitive? I have a meeting due to finish by 12 so should hopefully be able to check the thread around then.

[OrangeRKN]

Should be

Did DML post too late yesterday that we lost the streak?

[sawyerpip]

Yes, the days are measured midnight to midnight so our streak was broken. Everyone else posted so two of the other tribes are on a 2 day streak (and eligible for SAVE powers) and Curls's tribe is on a 1 day streak.

[DML]

Sorry, yesterday was insane. Will try and be about, but WHAT THE HELL IS THE TACTICS HERE I HAVE NO IDEA

[sawyerpip]

Rubber Soul - Sugar
Revolver - The Guardian ranks the mainline Zeldas
Abbey Road - The Banner Saga - What the good peeps from Bioware did next
A Hard Day's Night - Pun Pong
Beatles for Sale - NFTs
Yellow Submarine - CBeebies
Sgt Pepper - What's the most overrated game of all time?

Posting here as I may get caught up in work in case someone has time to take over.

[site23]

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - What's the most overrated game of all time?
The Beatles - Ghost Members
A Hard Day's Night - Pun-Pong
Help! - Name That Film

With The Beatles - The Current Chart Songs That You Hate
Let It Be - Detestable Twats on Twitter

Yellow Submarine - CBeebies

[Qikz]

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - What's the most overrated game of all time?
The Beatles - Ghost Members
A Hard Day's Night - Pun-Pong
Help! - Name That Film

With The Beatles - The Current Chart Songs That You Hate
Let It Be - Detestable Twats on Twitter

Abbey Road - The Banner Saga - What the good peeps from Bioware did next
The Beatles - Ghost Members
Revolver - The Guardian ranks the mainline Zeldas
Help! - Name That Film
A Hard Day's Night - Pun-Pong
With The Beatles - The Current Chart Songs That You Hate
Rubber Soul - Sugar
Sgt Pepper's Lonely Heart Club Band - What's the most overrated game of all time?
Yellow Submarine - CBeebies
Let It Be - Detestable Twats on Twitter
Beatles for Sale - NFTs
The Best of the Beatles - What's the best Beatles album?
Past Masters - Dead Thread Redemption

Please Please Me - This is one but it doesn't exist.

Sent this in already.