Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens

Oh Aaron why you?! The good truly die too young. Uh, goodnight sweet prince and something of angels sing thee to thy something.

PCCD: I appreciate your points and understand that it is possible to carve out various scenarios upon where voting for either Smurphy or Nood would make tactical sense, but from a team point of view, I simply can't see the lone Mafia member sacrificing his partner. It's illogical. Sure, as I have stated previously, if the vote was a landslide, then it would make sense to go along with the pack. I don't think we are going to agree though, regardless.

Thinking about it I could see where voting Smurph could work. If he gets lynched we don't find out his role and we're back to "was he/wasn't he?" arguing between me & aaron. Doesn't make sense to mafia kill him though since there was a pretty strong lobby that thought Smurph wasn't the detective. Given the extra day's shouting Smurph might've gotten lynched and it could've taken Aaron & maybe someone else down with him.

If this is all Goat's handywork then :lol:

Herbi wrote:Oblomov Boblomov - Deceased - Jumped out a window
smurphy - Deceased Detective - Shotgun blast to the chest
Zenigame
Cuttooth
Mini E
Irene Demova
The Master - Deceased - Death by Firing Mob
Drumstick
HM
PCCD
AJ Styles - Deceased - Thrown into the River Cade
aaronayl1 - Deceased Townsfolk - Shot in the head

Why is Aaron written in green? :shifty:

Zenigame wrote:
Herbi wrote:Oblomov Boblomov - Deceased - Jumped out a window
smurphy - Deceased Detective - Shotgun blast to the chest
Zenigame
Cuttooth
Mini E
Irene Demova
The Master - Deceased - Death by Firing Mob
Drumstick
HM
PCCD
AJ Styles - Deceased - Thrown into the River Cade
aaronayl1 - Deceased Townsfolk - Shot in the head

Why is Aaron written in green?

Detective seered him

I'm not gonna be around during the day - I am 100% townsfolk - genuinely. I am suspicious of HM but also Cuttooth - not sure why... something doesn't add up and I get the feeling he's playing a very clever game...

See y'all later

Nearly four and no votes? WTF?

I'll get the ball rolling with +1 Mini E.

Mini E - 1

I'm shockdified :shock:

Put me down for abstaining.

PCCD wrote:I'm shockdified

About what?

Abstaining?! You can't be serious.

Cuttooth wrote:Abstaining?! You can't be serious.

Oh fine put me down for Mini E

EDIT: That's with a lot of scepticism btw

I'm suspicious of HM and Mini E so will likely vote for one of them. As it looks like the majority (well, 2 others) are going for Mini E I'll do so too.

PostRe: Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens by HM » Mon Mar 22, 2010 4:27 pm

Mini E

This isn't going to end well for any of us. Me because I'll end up dead and you because you'll still have no mafia :fp:

Guys I'm gonna put it in really simple language - i am NOT mafia. Someone has played a very good game, either PCCD who is suddenly seen as not being mafia (although I don't believe he is either) , HM who i really have no idea about, or someone who voted not to kill off smurphy and has played an extremely clever play in that they now seem immune from being mafia.

If you kill me off then you are going to have one more dead townsfolk now, one more dead townsfolk tonight, and very, VERY limited time to find out who the mafia is/are. Look back through the thread and you will see that I've done very little suspicious. Whoever it was who was/is suspecting me because I took the piss and spoke russian with someone for a bit to wind you all up, is absolutely ridiculous. I translated it all correctly afterwards and it was all completely harmless.

I am NOT mafia. Unlike Nood, I'm not lying down and taking this because you guys are shooting yourselves in the foot if you kill me off. It's ridiculous.

Mini E wrote::fp: This isn't going to end well for any of us. Me because I'll end up dead and you because you'll still have no mafia

Pretty sure Jamie GR basically owned up to be being Mafia when smurphy outed him, hence why some of us were prepared to go along with the latter. So we've at least got one in the bag.

Mini E wrote:Guys I'm gonna put it in really simple language - i am NOT mafia. Someone has played a very good game, either PCCD who is suddenly seen as not being mafia (although I don't believe he is either) , HM who i really have no idea about, or someone who voted not to kill off smurphy and has played an extremely clever play in that they now seem immune from being mafia.

But they're not though - AJ was killed just yesterday and he was voted for Nood.

+1 for Mini E

at everyone jumping on the bandwagon once 2 people have voted at the beginning and it's clearly gonna be a whitewash :lol:

One of you is an extremely clever mafia member :lol:

Busy today then...

Aaron is in Green because he is a known Townsfolk as opposed to smurphy being the known Detective in blue.

I'll be on at 8 with the verdict, currently with only 1 name mentioned a majority exists.

Mini E wrote:One of you is an extremely clever mafia member

Drumstick wrote:
Mini E wrote:One of you is an extremely clever mafia member

If this turns out to be true I will worship you forever :lol:

You know what, scratch my vote for Mini E. I don't think he's Mafia (or HM for that matter).

Mafia: Welcome to Cadeby Citizens

Who is online

Affiliates