Pedz wrote:Skarjo wrote:Pedz wrote:Skarjo wrote:Snowballadeer wrote:Thread title not particularly accurate:
I don't think it's fair to call the model of multiple SKUs 'double dipping' in Pokemon's case, as I genuinely don't think it was ever really expected for anyone to buy both versions of any particular gen. Especially in the earlier gens where it wouldn't matter if you bought both because you'd still need a second GameBoy to get all the 'mon on one cart, I think it's pretty clear that the intention was to split the gen across multiple players and have them trade.
Same with the generational Third versions like Yellow and Crystal; they always struck me as GOTY-style editions for people who didn't jump in at release. I don't know anyone who bought both the flagship titles AND the same-gen follow ups. I only ever picked up the other versions much later (like a decade) on for collector reasons rather than to play them.
Everyone I knew would buy the flagship titles and the same gen follow up, myself included.
Really? Would you buy both the flagship or pick just one?
And the follow up too?
YOU MUG.
Mostly buy one flagship and the same gen followup. This is imo way better for the way people that I knew bought the games. Instead of buying the exact game twice with an extra tower in one version this way the get 2 new islands to explore.
I have bought both flagships, though. Only once or twice.
I guess for me there was never enough content to justify getting the same gen follow ups. I've got them all now but that because I went on a bit a collecting spree and got a bloody fantastic deal from a mate who was leaving the country and selling off his kids gooseberry fool. (I think it was like 200GBP for a 3DSXL and Pokemon X, Y, Sun, Moon, Ultra Sun, Ultra Moon and White 2).
The kid only put like three hours into each of them, can't believe he kept buying a franchise he clearly didn't like.