Buffalo wrote:...I hope it keeps going for a couple more years, but those comments from the gaffer sound like nails being hammered into the games coffin. If it celebrates a 2 year anniversary, I’ll be surprised.
I understand your view, Buff, and I kinda had that view too. It has been driven by folk reading "bad news"... and I'm not having a go at Jiggles for posting that story; it was widely reported. However, it's always worth seeing what other media outlets are reporting to get a bigger picture. Here's what Forbes had to say in an article they published in September.
Forbes wrote:There’s a general sense that Marvel’s Avengers has been something of a failure, and yet, it’s not clear that reality bears that out. Square Enix initially said that Avengers didn’t sell as well as they wanted it to, but Square Enix also has notoriously high expectations of its games, so it’s unclear how much should be read into that.
Looking at the NPD numbers for the last year, you may be surprised to see where Marvel’s Avengers lands. Here’s the top 10 list for the last 12 months in the US, according to NPD... (the game was the seventh best-selling title over the past year in the USA; above Animal Crossing)
Forbes then wrote:So, Marvel’s Avengers is not only the 7th best-selling game of the last 12 months, but it is the only original game on that list. I mean, look at what it’s competing against. Three sports titles that make this list every year. Two massively popular Switch games. A massively popular PS5 launch game. A Call of Duty and Assassin’s Creed installment, decade plus-long best-selling franchises, each.
That’s… actually quite good, in context.
And if you think that this is only because of a surge of sales right at launch, that does not seem to be the case either. On a separate NPD chart for Xbox in August, Marvel’s Avengers launched up from 16th place to 8th place this past month, the result of both a free weekend which got people playing, and then the War for Wakanda expansion, which drew more players in. The expansion was free, but it appears to have driven game sales to some extent.
This appears to be why Avengers is continuing to make content going forward. Again, we aren’t getting any actual figures from Crystal Dynamics, but what they’ve said is that they were very happy with the reaction to War for Wakanda, and cosmetic offerings like MCU skins seem to be doing well for them, one of the only monetization methods of the game. Landing on a top ten list of sales for the year as an original offering is no small feat, given the other games on that list, and I do think Square Enix may have undersold just how well did Avengers did. I mean it wasn’t some crazy breakout smash hit, clearly, and yet it does seem to have done/be doing well enough to live on into 2022. The whole year? Another full expansion to come? That remains to be seen, but fans of the game should be encouraged by what we’re seeing here.
I wonder if this is panning out rather like FF XIV, No Man's Sky and Fallout 76; games that were generally regarded in a bad light at launch but, despite plenty of negative press (and plenty of it justified!) the games developed and improved. Will Avengers last for years? Maybe not. But it's not quite the big failure it is commonly portrayed as; at least not in terms of sales.
I haven't played it yet. I hope to give it a go tomorrow!