Game of the Year:
DEATHLOOP
It Takes Two
Metroid Dread
Psychonauts 2
Ratchet & Clank
Resident Evil Village
Out of what I've played (bolded) I'd give it to Deathloop by some margin, but it's a travesty that Monster Hunter Rise didn't get a nomination (and it appearing under best RPG is an indictment of genres in general). For point of comparison, Monster Hunter Rise has the same metacritic average of 88 as Deathloop, It Takes Two, Ratchet and Clank
and Metroid Dread (Psychonauts 2 is the "winner" by 1 point on 89 and Resident Evil Village is bottom from this shortlist on 84).
Best Indie:
12 Minutes
Death's Door
Kena
Inscryption
Loop Hero
Haven't played any of these so I am disappointed in myself! I am planning on playing Death's Door when it launches soon on Switch at least.
For me I'm too often out of agreement at the nominations stage to then put any value into who wins - best art direction and best music for example should both have NEO The World Ends With You and No More Heroes 3 in them (which I'd also have put in best RPG and best action game respectively, and probably both in my GOTY shortlist).