David Lynch and Mark Frost just tweeted this at the same time:
Dear Twitter Friends: That gum you like is going to come back in style. #damngoodcoffee
https://twitter.com/DAVID_LYNCH/status/ ... 1690569730https://twitter.com/mfrost11/status/518060486156230656 They must know what they're doing. Surely they can't be trolling us like that, it would just be cruel. Could Season 3 FINALLY be a done deal?
UPDATE: And it is! Showtime have greenlit a 9 episode (EDIT: 18 episode) third season, with all episodes to be written by Mark Frost and David Lynch, and directed by David Lynch.
FUUUUUUUUUUUCK.
Episode 1/2 (2 hour premiere) reviews:
âReview: In âTwin Peaks,â an Old Log Learns Some New Tricksâ (The New York Times)
âMr. Lynchâs mastery of tension persists,â writes James Poniewozik âThe script, by him and Mr. Frost, recognizes the power of silence and anticipation. And Mr. Lynch, who is directing the entire revival, still has his penchant for dualities and eerie beauty.â
But he also notes that the first installment of the new âTwin Peaksâ is a bit tonally inconsistent, observing that, âAt times it feels as if a nostalgic 1990 version of the show is alternating scenes with a colder, harder-edged 2017 version. Whether and how the two come together may determine whether this sample, one-ninth of a unitary work, has staying power beyond the class-reunion phase.â
ââTwin Peaks: The Returnâ and the Search for David Lynchâ (The New Yorker)
Film critic Richard Brody is less enthusiastic about Lynchâs return to television. âI donât know whether he filmed âThe Returnâ sequentially but the first hour and a half feels like a filmmaker under cobwebs, working not merely tentatively but conventionally, following patterns rather than inventing, recording and divulging information rather than creating,â he writes.
âSplendid âTwin Peaksâ Reboot Is Very Much Itself in Its Long-Awaited Return on Showtimeâ (Los Angeles Times)
In one of many reviews that contextualize âTwin Peaks: The Returnâ within a 21st-century prestige TV landscape the original series helped to create, Robert Lloyd notes that, âIn some respects this is a show that has clearly been made in a world that has seen âThe Sopranosâ and everything âThe Sopranosâ made bankable. Yet it remains very much a David Lynch film; and if it doesnât aim to replicate the mood of the original â the stylistic cribs from 1950s big-screen romances and B-grade thrillers that animated the original series have been tamped down â it is more like that âTwin Peaksâ than like anything else on television.â
âTV Review: âTwin Peaks: The Returnââ (Variety)
In an ambivalent review that questions Lynchâs apparent lack of interest in human nature, Sonia Saraiya concludes that, ââTwin Peaks: The Returnâ is weird and creepy and slow. But it is interesting. The show is very stubbornly itself â not quite film and not quite TV, rejecting both standard storytelling and standard forms. Itâs not especially fun to watch and it can be quite disturbing. But there is never a sense that you are watching something devoid of vision or intention. Lynchâs vision is so total and absolute that he can get away with what wouldnât be otherwise acceptable.â
ââTwin Peaksâ Is Back, as Strange and Stunning as Everâ (Uproxx)
Alan Sepinwall expresses some relief that the premiere ânever felt like a brand cash-in â Lynch and Frost returning to their most famous creation for lack of other ideas â nor like a show that had no business existing outside its original time and space.â He adds that, âfor all of its self-indulgence with pacing and content, and for all off its opaqueness even by âTwin Peaksâ standards, this felt thrillingly alive and fresh, even as it was continuing a story that Lynch and Frost had to abandon back in 1991 due to low ratings and various bad creative choices.â
ââTwin Peaks: The Returnâ Is Riveting, Horrifying, and Patience-Taxingâ (Vulture)
In an appraisal that seizes on the rebootâs difficult, experimental feel, Matt Zoller Seitz writes, âI was riveted,â and recommends watching without interruption, in a dark room, âon the largest screen possible.â
âBut,â he wrote, âI didnât see much evidence that the new âTwin Peaksâ is going to pivot anytime soon and turn into the show that people remember, or think they remember.â
âIn Its Nightmarish Two-Part Return, âTwin Peaksâ Is Pure Lynchian Horrorâ (A.V. Club)
âIf you were looking forward to a return of the sometimes campy, sometimes cozy humor of the original two seasons of âTwin Peaks,â this premiere could come as a shock,â Emily L. Stephens warns in her recap of Sunday nightâs episodes.
But, she adds, âIf you, like me, had heard whispers that this revival was going to be Lynchâs vision almost entirely unconstrained by network notes â if you, like me, were buckled in for two hours of uncompromising surrealism and horror, this premiere delivered.â