GRcade

Why have 4 people already rated Nintendo?

HSH28 » Tue Jun 10, 2014 11:32 am wrote:Criterion's New Game (Megaton)

Woo concept art that was the most interesting thing at E3 for me

Mockmaster » Tue Jun 10, 2014 12:32 pm wrote:Why have 4 people already rated Nintendo?

Staydead
Gario

So we have two people who need to own up.

suzzopher » Tue Jun 10, 2014 12:37 pm wrote:

Mockmaster » Tue Jun 10, 2014 12:32 pm wrote:Why have 4 people already rated Nintendo?

Staydead
Gario

So we have two people who need to own up.

I haven't.

Maybe you should allow revoting.

NickSCFC » Tue Jun 10, 2014 11:41 am wrote:Maybe you should allow revoting.

It is allowed ya big goof

Microsoft - C
EA - D
Ubisoft - A
Sony - A

Microsoft - B (That's how you do a press conference, but it lacked that blowout game)
EA - C (Usual boring conference with only the Battlefront footage impressing me)
Ubisoft - C (Again, I found this boring)
Sony - A (What can I say, it had EVERYTHING, and then Uncharted 4 footage )

For me this has been a great E3 with the focus on games and only a small smattering of crap like dancing.

Microsoft - A
Ubisoft - A
Sony - B

MS - A-
EA - C+
Ubisoft - B-
Sony - B+

Irene Demova » Tue Jun 10, 2014 12:35 pm wrote:

HSH28 » Tue Jun 10, 2014 11:32 am wrote:Criterion's New Game (Megaton)

Woo concept art that was the most interesting thing at E3 for me

The concept art wasn't what was interesting. The prototype gameplay footage is what I found exciting.

Mockmaster wrote:Why have 4 people already rated Nintendo?

It's up to six now . I guess it's probably the same folk who awarded a rating of D to Microsoft and/or Sony. They're raging against the machine(s).

Let's see how Edge viewed things.....

SONY
Microsoft

The final conference has finished so remember to get your votes in.

Nintendo - B

Its a B- I think at the moment.

If you're counting it on just the actual conference I'd say it was about a B+ from Nintendo.

With all their Treehouse stuff though and the Smash Tournament it's most certainly an A from me. For one they actually had so many games I'd want to play and also they showed off real gameplay, done by the people who actually know how to play games rather than stupid PR people.

I'm struggling to get my head around people awarding a 'D' rating to either the MS, Sony or Nintendo presentations. I wonder if these guys genuinely feel that way.

Microsoft - B
EA - D
Ubisoft - C
Sony - B
Nintendo - A

jawafour » Wed Jun 11, 2014 3:10 pm wrote:I'm struggling to get my head around people awarding a 'D' rating to either the MS, Sony or Nintendo presentations. I wonder if these guys genuinely feel that way.

Probably just fanboys or PC people.

jawafour » Wed Jun 11, 2014 2:10 pm wrote:I'm struggling to get my head around people awarding a 'D' rating to either the MS, Sony or Nintendo presentations. I wonder if these guys genuinely feel that way.

Sony : A, B
Microsoft : D
Nintendo: D
Ubisoft: D