Pancake wrote:Pacman wrote:My defense is really rather simple.
Biggest evidence that Pacman is not a cannibal:Pancake wrote:Pacman is only up because mcjihge2 died. He has been seered as an omnivore.
I have been seered as an omnivore because I am an omnivore. If there were an extra alpha in play that would mean this game had THREE alphas.
Lagamorph wrote:I don't think there's another Alpha, 3 just seems too many.
My buddy dying is the
perfect cannibal play to not only eliminate one omnivore (RIP mcjihge2) but to waste the group's time lynching the buddy. As it happens, something did come of him being killed while buddied up with another omnivore (me) and I shared it via PM only with Errkal. I'm hoping he can vouch for me on that, as we believe it is the related to why there were no kills last night.
But if my logic is sound, Songwriter is the only player who could be a regular cannibal. So if he is an omnivore, we do have a third Alpha.
I'm trying to understand your reasoning and what I come up with is...
As you say, there are two possible realities.
Pancake wrote:1. The final cannibal is just a regular cannibal, or;
2. There is a third Alpha
And Mr. Pancake you agreed that
Pancake wrote:...if the first of these scenarios is true then the last cannibal must be Songwriter.
Since I've been seered, I must be an alpha if I'm a cannibal. Since that means there's an alpha.
Songwriter must be the cannibal.
According to your own deduction, that is.
The flaw may lie in your second assumption
2. Diabolito and Pancake are good because their respective buddies, Laga and Nun (who took part in the ritual yesterday and are thus good according to the first assumption), have confirmed that they did not receive a PM about their buddy
If we're entertaining the notion of two cannibals (which we are, to incriminate me) then it stands to reason a complete pair of buddies could have both been cannibals. If this is true, then not only have they gotten away with murder but they have slipped by our suspicions completely.
If you want to run for mayor with another name in place of mine I will volunteer for the event and summon mcjihge2 to prove my innocence.